Using "God is dead" as a premise and "God rises again in what we want" as a solution simultaneously betrays two thoughts that both deserve greater respect: traditional Friedrich Nietzsche, reducing his tragic diagnosis to a lyrical pretext; and betrays the Christian theology of the Resurrection, reducing it to a collective inspiration of good intentions.
Given that the topic could lend itself to easy misunderstandings and sterile controversies, it is appropriate to clarify things immediately: the target of these lines is not Francesco Guccini, passed away today in Pavana, fraction of Sambuca Pistoiese.
One can not appreciate the thought of this singer-songwriter — and who writes, in truth, he never shared it - even though he unreservedly recognized his talent and the place he deserves in the history of Italian songwriting. It's not him, today, the problem, but an article appeared on Future, newspaper of the Italian Episcopal Conference, the signature of Umberto Folena (see article who), who in commemorating the musician writes a sentence that would deserve much more caution from those who publish in the newspaper of the Bishops of Italy. Quoting the famous song God is dead (cf.. text who), this colleague observes that in the text in question «God is no longer at the center of man's thoughts […] but God rises again: “In what we believe, in what we want, in the world we will make”». And he adds, of his own, that it is «a hope that is neither vague nor vain, but supported by a faith". Statement, this, which is not a neutral paraphrase at all: it is an approval.
Like this, directly from the columns of Future, we ignore that the Resurrection is not a human project. Let's try to be surgical, because the material requires it: the Resurrection of Christ, in the Catholic faith, it is not an event that depends on our belief, by our will, or from the world we will build. It's exactly the opposite: it is a historical-salvific fact that precedes faith and establishes it, not that it depends on it. Christ was resurrected on the third day, really and physically, regardless of who believed it and who didn't. Incredulous and terrified, the apostles themselves had to surrender to the evidence of an empty tomb and a living Lord (cf.. LC 24,36-43), not the other way around.
«The formula cited by Umberto Folena — «in what we believe, in what we want, in the world we will make" — overturns this logic: makes the Resurrection a projection of the human will, an immanent project, something that happens within history and at the hands of man. It is theology reversed: not God who saves man, but the man who, believing and wanting intensely enough, “rises up” God within his own collective project. In other words: if the Resurrection really depended on what we believe, we want or build, At that time “It gave” it would merely become the name we give to our best collective intentions, that is, something that exists as long as we continue to want it and which would disappear if we stopped believing in it or committing ourselves. It is the exact opposite of the Christian faith, for which Christ was truly resurrected, Once for all, regardless of who knew it, believed it or wanted it, as demonstrated precisely by the initial disbelief of the apostles in the face of the fait accompli (cf.. LC 24,11). And all this, which from a theological point of view is an authentic aberration of the entire mystery of salvation, it certainly cannot be called "a hope supported by a faith", because without a line of distinction, without a single reference to the Creed, it is an operation that any newspaper could also afford, the official organ of the Bishops, absolutely not.
There is more and it concerns the other side of the coin: the death of God, not his resurrection. When that genius Friedrich Nietzsche wrote «God is dead» (God is dead), he was not composing a consolatory song about the ultimate destiny of the sacred, but I was diagnosing, with ruthless clarity, the collapse of the moral foundations of the modern West. His was a tragic announcement, not a springboard for an optimistic humanism. He knew well that the man who killed God has no idea how to bear the weight of that act:
"God is dead! God remains dead! And we killed him! How will we console ourselves, the killers of all killers? […] It's not too big, for us, the greatness of this action? We must not become gods ourselves, to at least appear worthy of it?» (F. Nietzsche, The Gay Science, aphorism 125).
A man forced to become god just to support the void left by God: nothing but cheap consolation like the They're just songs, as another very talented singer-songwriter sings, Edoardo Bennato.
Use “God is dead” as a premise and "God rises again in what we want" as a solution simultaneously betrays two thoughts that both deserve greater respect: traditional Friedrich Nietzsche, reducing his tragic diagnosis to a lyrical pretext; and betrays the Christian theology of the Resurrection, reducing it to a collective inspiration of good intentions, careless about it, as the Apostle Paul teaches, our faith can be born or it can die:
"But if Christ has not been raised, therefore our preaching is in vain and your faith is also in vain" (1Color 15,14).
It is therefore not up for debate whether Francesco Guccini had faith, he didn't have it, or cultivated - as Umberto Folena writes in his conclusion - "an ever cultivated hope". It's his business, now entrust yourself to the judgment of God, the true one. The question that remains and which concerns not Guccini but whoever commemorated him in this way is another: can a newspaper that presents itself as the voice of the Italian Bishops publish, without a single word of doctrinal distinction, an equivalence between the Resurrection of Christ and the collective good will of man? Such an equivalence is not theologically neutral: expresses a clearly heterodox thought of modernist origin condemned by Saint Pius Feeding of Dominic's Sheep(1907), that is, the reduction of dogmatic truth, objective and revealed, a projection of the immanent religious feeling of the believing subject. And if this happens without anyone, in the editorial office of the Bishops' newspaper notice this, where we should look for a healthy ecclesiology today, maybe on the Manifesto, maybe up Micromega? Undoubtedly, the third page of Manifesto as well as the culture articles of Micromegaare and remain of a highly superior level to those of Future.
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of:
Editions The island of Patmos
n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff,
the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Padre-Ariel-foto-2025-piccola.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150father arielHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngfather ariel2026-08-07 13:09:072026-08-07 13:36:22Francesco Guccini is dead but God is not
ENZO BIANCHI AND THE DEATH OF CAMILLO RUINI: PLEASE PRAY IN FRONT OF A DECEASED, THE ACCOUNTS ARE NOT SETTLED
«Even the card. Ruini is dead! A clergyman who caused many in the church to suffer. She gave the face of her stepmother to the church, the face of the church seeking authority, influence and seat among the powerful. But he did not have approval from the card. Martini nor by Pope Francis" (Enzo Bianchi).
When the Church accompanies one of its children to death he does not convene a historic tribunal, it does not open a political debate and does not proceed with an ideological verification of the life of the deceased.
The Church does something much simpler e, at the same time, infinitely deeper: pray. He does so because he looks at death in the light of the victory of the risen Christ, according to the proclamation of the Apostle: «Death was swallowed up for victory. Where, death, your victory? Where, death, your sting?» (1 Color 15,54-55). For this reason, the general premises of the Funeral Rite remind us that the deceased remains a brother in the faith and that the entire ecclesial community gathers around him to accompany him with prayer, offering the Eucharistic sacrifice and raising suffrages. In fact, the Church prays for the deceased because it believes that corporal death does not interrupt their belonging to Christ and that, for this, the prayer of the Church can still benefit them.
It is from this faith that we must start when looking at the death of a Christian, not first of all by the role he held in the Church, from the battles he fought or from the judgments that history will formulate on his person and his work. All this belongs to legitimate historical judgment and can be discussed and even severely criticized. In the face of death, But, the Church looks first of all at the baptized person. It is not without significance that, in the official verification of the death of the Roman Pontiff, he who bore that pontifical name for years was called three times by his baptismal name: in the face of death, in a sense, everyone returns to the origin. This is why the first word of the Church is not judgement, but prayer, because the deceased is first and foremost a child of the Church entrusted to the mercy of God and accompanied by the intercession of his brothers.
It is in the light of this faith that what happened after the death of Cardinal Camillo Ruini must be considered. It is not of interest here to establish whether he was right or wrong in the great ecclesial battles of recent decades, nor discuss the historical judgment on his vision of the Church. The question is another and concerns the reaction aroused by his disappearance, because precisely at the moment in which the Church entrusts one of her children to the mercy of God and accompanies him with prayer, the Christian is called to measure his words and his judgments with the very meaning of Christian death.
They were not missed, in the hours following his death attempts to read this figure almost exclusively through political and ideological categories. The Daily, the 16 June 2026, published the article by Francesco Antonio Grana: «Cardinal Camillo Ruini has died. Interference in politics, proximity to the right, the relationship with Berlusconi: history of the Italian Richelieu»; The Manifesto was titled «Ruini, religion as a political instrument". Certainly legitimate readings on a historical and journalistic level, but which show how easy it is to continue discussing a person in terms of sides, influence and power even at the moment of his death. And so, in this same vein, a few hours after the death of Cardinal Camillo Ruini, Enzo Bianchi intervened on his X profile by writing:
«Even the card. Ruini is dead! A clergyman who caused many in the church to suffer. She gave the face of her stepmother to the church, the face of the church seeking authority, influence and seat among the powerful. But he did not have approval from the card. Martini nor by Pope Francis".
The question that emerges from those words it concerns Cardinal Ruini much less than it concerns Enzo Bianchi himself: which conception of Christian death manifests who, in front of a deceased person, first of all he feels the need to reopen an ecclesial controversy? It is a question that does not arise from controversy, but by the faith of the Church. A militant atheist who continues his polemic in front of a dead person acts according to the logic he professes, although he often avoids doing so because he shows the respect for death that some Christians do not have. Instead, by Enzo Bianchi, who for decades spoke of evangelical spirituality and eccentric monastic life, becoming a celebrity disputed by Italian bishops who competed to invite him to hold conferences in their cathedrals during the years of Cardinal Camillo Ruini's long presidency of the CEI, one would expect at least the elementary memory of what the Church does in front of a deceased person.
In this context the spiritual testament of Camillo Ruini takes on a meaning that goes far beyond the personal story of its author. Anyone expecting self-defense from a protagonist of Italian ecclesial life will be surprised, because those pages do not contain claims or attempts to justify their historical choices. What emerges instead is the confession of one's own insufficiencies, the request for forgiveness and the invocation of divine mercy. He acknowledges that he has sometimes acted harshly, he asks for forgiveness, confesses the smallness of his faith and presents himself simply as a man called to appear before God. This is where the contrast becomes evident. On the one hand there is a man who has reached the end of his life and entrusts himself to divine mercy; on the other who, in the face of that death, feels the urgency of reopening the accounting of ecclesial controversies. Which of the two is looking at death in a Christian way: Camillo Ruini or Enzo Bianchi?
Even more so it is not a question of establishing who was right in the controversies that have crossed the Italian Church in the last forty years. It is not a question of deciding whether this Cardinal was a great ecclesial protagonist or a questionable protagonist. Nor is it a question of denying Enzo Bianchi the right to radically disagree with his vision, but to understand what happens when a Christian dies. Because there is a substantial difference between historical judgment and the polemical use of death: the first is legitimate; the second instead reveals a loss of the Christian meaning of death. When a man's coffin becomes the latest battlefield of a decades-long ecclesiastical war, when the body of a deceased is used as polemical material and the death of a brother in the faith becomes an opportunity to settle scores that have remained open, It's not just the respect due to the dead that is damaged: the very faith in God's judgment is called into question, in mercy, in the communion of saints and in eternal life. Because of this, in the end, the problem is not Cardinal Camillo Ruini. The problem is us. Because if faced with the death of a Christian we no longer know how to pray, if faced with a spiritual testament imbued with a request for forgiveness and mercy we only know how to reopen old processes, if we continue to think like faction militants at the very moment in which the Church invites us to pray for a deceased brother, then we have not simply lost our sense of proportion, but something essential about the Christian faith has been lost. When this happens, prophecy gives way to controversy, which ends up imposing itself even in the face of death.
It must be said that Cardinal Camillo Ruini, nicknamed “Cardinal Thin”, he did not fail to write in his will:
«When Pope Francis was elected I rejoiced and, as much as I could, I was immediately a supporter of his. Even today I rejoice and thank him for his extraordinary evangelizing enthusiasm. However, I must confess that I find myself in an uncomfortable situation, certainly not for personal reasons but because I struggle to understand some orientations that seem to me to reopen wounds, after the Council they were barely medicated. I humbly ask the Lord to convince me internally that the Church is his and that he himself takes care of it, beyond our human sights".
This is not the place to address issues that would require other spaces. However, it remains difficult not to observe that many of the most serious contemporary ecclesial problems have their roots in the long and complex pontificate of John Paul II, of which Camillo Ruini was one of the most influential figures, arriving gangrenous at the pontificate of Benedict XVI - under which he continued his mandate as President of the CEI and Vicar General of the Diocese of Rome for another two years - and in certain respects out of control during the complex pontificate of Francis, everything to be understood before even being studied in the face of a very difficult situation inherited by him from the two previous pontificates, which he tried to cope with in situations that were very difficult to manage. It is therefore striking to read in his will the confession of the difficulty in understanding some ecclesial orientations specific to Francis' pontificate. If the profound meaning of these events was not fully clear to him during his earthly life, it is reasonable to think that today, coming face to face with God, understand it with a fullness that remains closed to those who, like us living people, look at history from within its inevitable partiality.
Florence, 22 June 2026
.
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of: Editions The island of Patmos n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff, the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
.
.
.
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Padre-Simone-isola-piccola.jpeg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150Father SimoneHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngFather Simone2026-06-22 11:36:182026-06-25 15:52:19Enzo Bianchi and the death of Camillo Ruini: one prays in front of a deceased person, scores are not settled
«MY MOTHER MUST NOT KNOW». WHERE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE POPES IS BORN AND DIES
If the Pontiff has not been informed, who did not inform him? If he was misinformed, who misinformed him? And if he was even deceived, who deceived him? What is striking, in the examination of quite a few cases, is that these figures almost always remain nameless, faceless and without precise identification.
In the exercise of government in general, perhaps in the pastoral one of the Church in particular, the principle according to which the king cannot make mistakes applies and, if he were to make a mistake, someone else has to pay for him. This principle tends to protect not so much the person himself, as the institution that it is called upon to cover or, in the case of the papacy, to embody (cf.. Mt 16, 18-19).
To stay in the political sphere and represent everything with an effective example: according to the article 89 of the Constitution of the Italian Republic, all acts of the Head of State are countersigned, as politically irresponsible. The countersignature in fact transfers the political and legal responsibility for the act from the President of the Republic to the proposing ministers or to the Government, while guaranteeing the formal regularity of the measure.
If we move from the political sphere to the spiritual one instead we discover something substantially different: while the Head of State of the Italian Republic, like other Heads of State governed by different but similar constitutional systems, Republican president or monarch, is not responsible for political acts carried out in the exercise of its functions, even though he could be called to answer for serious crimes against the State, the Roman Pontiff is not judged by any human authority (cf.. Code of Canon Law, can. 1404: The first seat is judged by no one). His supreme power, milk, immediate and universal on the Church (cf.. can. 331) in fact he knows no superior earthly authority.
but yet, despite these immunities created to protect the office, of the Petrine ministry and his apostolic succession, the Roman Pontiff, unlike any other political figure, republican or monarchic, remains fully responsible for its own actions, of their own words, of one's works and omissions on a spiritual and moral level before God and before the Church. In fact, he enjoys total human legal immunity, but precisely for this reason his moral responsibility is not attenuated, quite the opposite: if anything it is increased by the singularity of his office and the absence of any superior earthly authority called to judge him. This regardless of the fact that, if necessary, someone may be exposed, sacrificed or called to pay in his place. In fact, these are dynamics attributable to government policy, sometimes even its most unscrupulous forms, which, however, have no relevance on a doctrinal level, ecclesiological or metaphysical. Before God there are no ministerial countersignatures, nor responsibilities transferable to others.
Over the last few decades However, that period has progressively established itself which I have already had the opportunity to define as the era of uninformed and kept in the dark Pontiffs.. In these cases, not even the ancient scapegoat sacrificed to save the sovereign who cannot make mistakes or be exposed for his own mistakes no longer pays.. Responsibility rather tends to dissolve in a generic lack of information, in news that would not have reached its destination, in filtered alerts, incomplete or even altered by others. And that this could happen occasionally is entirely plausible. No man, not even the Roman Pontiff, possesses the gift of omniscience. However, less plausible appears to be the fact that this explanation recurs with surprising regularity under different pontificates, in different eras and in profoundly different events. In fact, it is at this point that an inevitable question arises: if the Pontiff has not been informed, who did not inform him? If he was misinformed, who misinformed him? And if he was even deceived, who deceived him? What is striking, in the examination of quite a few cases, is that these figures almost always remain nameless, faceless and without precise identification.
Here's an example. Let's assume that within the micro-state of which the Roman Pontiff is sovereign, blatant and serious violations of human rights occur, even as he is particularly active on the international scene in calling out governments, supranational institutions and bodies to respect the dignity of the person and the protection of fundamental rights. It is in cases like these that various justifying mechanisms tend to be activated: we are talking about information that was not received, of news filtered along the way, of incomplete relationships, of collaborators who would not have reported, of apparatuses that would have shielded reality and so on. All subjects almost always shrouded in vagueness, nameless, of face and precise identity.
Vladimir Putin governs a federation that spans over seventeen million square kilometers and spans eleven time zones. Donald Trump presides over a federation that spans nearly ten million square kilometers and spans six time zones. Both, wanting, they could argue with some reasonableness that they are not able to know everything that happens in the most remote points of their territories, of the various central administrations and above all of the peripheral ones. The same argument can also be invoked by the Supreme Pontiff, sovereign of a state that extends for just over half a square kilometre? A state in which, to go from the Apostolic Palace to the Vatican Gardens, it is not necessary to face an intercontinental flight, cross deserts, mountain ranges or tropical forests, nor even change the time on the clock to adapt to different time zones. However, also in this case, it may happen that certain news stories undertake such long journeys, tortuous and bumpy that they will never be able to reach their final destination.
The distance between the Vatican City State and Gaza is considerable. However, this does not prevent - rightly - from raising our voices in defense of the tormented Palestinian people, as well as other peoples deprived of their rights in even more distant lands. It may be, however, that this constant and necessary reminder of human rights violations committed thousands of kilometers away sometimes makes it more difficult to deal with the different Gazas and their respective tortured Palestinians who may find themselves right inside the sacred palaces of that half square kilometer.
It is perhaps due to the lack of information? Can be. It's because of filtered news, withheld or never reached their destination? It could be this too. Anything can be. As it can be, to quote the late and unforgettable Giuni Russo: «My mother must not know that I want to go to Alghero in the company of a foreigner» (cf.. who).
One thing, however, remains out of question on a doctrinal and juridical level: the Roman Pontiff is not judged by any human authority. But perhaps precisely for this reason he is called to answer in a particular way before God for his own thoughts, of their own words, of one's works and omissions, without anyone being able to countersign his documents to relieve him of responsibility or assume responsibility, if necessary, political responsibility in his place. Because if the sovereign can be protected by men, the question always remains open of how he will be judged by Him who knows perfectly what men have seen, what they did not see and even what they preferred not to see. It is written:
"To whom much is given, much will be asked for; to whom men have committed much, It will ask the more " (LC 12, 48).
And before the divine tribunal it will be very difficult to say you don't know, that they were not informed or were deceived in half a square kilometre.
«MY MOTHER MUST NOT KNOW». WHERE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF PONTIFFS IS BORN AND WHERE IT DIES
If the Pontiff was not informed, who failed to inform him? If he was misinformed, who misinformed him? And if he was actually deceived, who deceived him? What is striking, upon examining not a few cases, is that such figures almost always remain without a name, without a face and without any precise identification.
In the exercise of government in general, and perhaps in that of the Church’s pastoral governance in particular, there operates a principle according to which the king cannot be wrong and, should he happen to err, someone else must pay in his place. This principle is intended to protect not so much the person himself as the institution he is called to occupy or, in the case of the papacy, to embody (cf. Mt 16, 18-19).
To remain within the political sphere and illustrate the matter with an effective example: according to Article 89 of the Constitution of the Italian Republic, all acts of the Head of State must be countersigned, since he is politically irresponsible. The countersignature transfers the political and legal responsibility for the act from the President of the Republic to the proposing ministers or to the Government, while at the same time guaranteeing the formal validity of the measure.
If we move from the political sphere to the spiritual one, we discover something substantially different: whereas the Head of State of the Italian Republic, like other Heads of State governed by different but analogous constitutional systems, whether republican president or monarch, is not accountable for political acts performed in the exercise of his office, although he may be called to answer for grave crimes against the State, the Roman Pontiff is judged by no human authority (cf. Code of Canon Lawi, can. 1404: The first seat is judged by no one). His supreme, full, immediate and universal power over the Church recognises no higher earthly authority (cf. can. 331).
Yet, despite these immunities established for the protection of the office, the Petrine ministry and its apostolic succession, the Roman Pontiff, unlike any other political figure, whether republican or monarchical, remains fully responsible for his acts, his words, his deeds and his omissions on the spiritual and moral plane before God and before the Church. He indeed enjoys complete juridical immunity before men, but precisely for this reason his moral responsibility is not diminished; quite the contrary: it is heightened by the singularity of his office and by the absence of any superior earthly authority called to judge him. This remains true regardless of the fact that, when circumstances require it, someone else may be exposed, sacrificed or called upon to pay in his place. Such dynamics belong to the sphere of governmental politics, at times even in its more ruthless forms, yet they possess no relevance whatsoever on the doctrinal, ecclesiological or metaphysical plane. Before God there are no ministerial countersignatures, nor responsibilities transferable to others.
During the past decades, however, there has gradually emerged what I once described as the era of Pontiffs who are uninformed and kept in the dark. In such cases, not even the ancient scapegoat sacrificed in order to save the sovereign who cannot err or be exposed for his own mistakes is called upon to pay. Responsibility tends instead to dissolve into a generic lack of information, into reports that allegedly never reached their destination, into notices filtered, incomplete or even altered by others. That such things may occasionally occur is entirely plausible. No man, not even the Roman Pontiff, possesses the gift of omniscience. Less plausible, however, is the fact that this explanation recurs with surprising regularity under different pontificates, in different periods and in circumstances profoundly unlike one another. It is at this point that an inevitable question arises: if the Pontiff was not informed, who failed to inform him? If he was misinformed, who misinformed him? And if he was actually deceived, who deceived him? What is striking, upon examining not a few cases, is that such figures almost always remain without a name, without a face and without any precise identification.
Let us take an example. Let us suppose that within the micro-State over which the Roman Pontiff is sovereign there occur manifest and serious violations of human rights, precisely while he is particularly active on the international stage in calling governments, institutions and supranational bodies to respect human dignity and safeguard fundamental rights. It is in cases such as these that various justificatory mechanisms are promptly set in motion: one hears of information that never arrived, of reports filtered along the way, of incomplete briefings, of collaborators who allegedly failed to report matters, of bureaucratic structures that supposedly screened reality from view, and so forth. All subjects almost invariably enveloped in vagueness and deprived of any clear name or identity.
Vladimir Putin governs a federation extending across more than seventeen million square kilometres and spanning eleven time zones. Donald Trump presides over a federation extending across nearly ten million square kilometres and spanning six time zones. Both, if they wished, could reasonably maintain that they are unable to know everything that takes place in the most remote corners of their territories, within the various central administrations and, above all, within the peripheral ones. May the same argument also be invoked by the Supreme Pontiff, sovereign of a State extending over little more than half a square kilometre? A State in which, in order to pass from the Apostolic Palace to the Vatican Gardens, there is no need to undertake an intercontinental flight, cross deserts, mountain ranges or tropical forests, nor even to adjust one’s watch to different time zones. Yet even in such a case it may happen that certain pieces of information undertake journeys so long, tortuous and hazardous that they never succeed in reaching their final destination.
The distance between the Vatican City State and Gaza is considerable. Yet this does not prevent the Holy See – rightly so – from raising its voice in defence of the long-suffering Palestinian people, just as it does for other peoples deprived of their rights in lands even more distant. It may be, however, that this constant and entirely justified concern for human rights violations committed thousands of kilometres away sometimes makes it more difficult to come to terms with the various Gazas and their respective suffering Palestinians who may be found within the sacred palaces of that half square kilometre.
Is it perhaps the fault of a lack of information? It may be. Is it the fault of reports filtered, withheld or never delivered to their destination? That too may be the case. Anything is possible. Just as it may be, to borrow the words of the late and unforgettable Giuni Russo: «My mother must not know that I want to go to Alghero in the company of a foreigner» (cf. here).
One thing, however, remains beyond dispute on both the doctrinal and juridical levels: the Roman Pontiff is judged by no human authority. Yet perhaps precisely for this reason he is called in a particular way to answer before God for his thoughts, his words, his deeds and his omissions, without anyone being able to countersign his acts in order to relieve him of responsibility or assume political responsibility in his stead. For if the sovereign may be protected by men, there remains the question of how he will be judged by Him who knows perfectly what men have seen, what they have not seen and even what they have preferred not to see. For it is written: «Everyone to whom much was given, of him much will be required; and from him to whom they entrusted much, they will demand the more» (Page 12:48).
And, quite frankly, before the divine tribunal it will be very difficult to claim not to have known, not to have been informed, or to have been deceived within half a square kilometre.
From The Island of Patmos, 7 June 2026
.
«MY MOTHER SHOULD NOT KNOW». WHERE IS BORN AND WHERE DOES THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE PONTIFFS DIE??
If the Pontiff was not informed, Who stopped reporting it?? If you were misinformed, who misreported it? And if he was even deceived, who deceived him? What attracts attention, when examining many cases, is that such figures almost always remain nameless, faceless and without precise identification.
In the exercise of government in general, and perhaps particularly in the pastoral government of the Church, governs the principle according to which the king cannot make a mistake and, if I were to make a mistake, someone else must pay instead. This principle tends to protect not so much the person themselves as the institution they are called to occupy or, in the case of the papacy, to embody (cf. Mt 16, 18-19).
To remain in the political sphere and represent all this with an effective example: according to the article 89 of the Constitution of the Italian Republic, all acts of the Head of State must be endorsed, because this is politically irresponsible. The endorsement transfers the political and legal responsibility for the act from the President of the Republic to the proposing ministers or the Government., while guaranteeing the formal regularity of the act.
If we move from the political sphere to the spiritual we discovered something substantially different: while the Head of State of the Italian Republic, like other Heads of State governed by different but analogous constitutional systems, whether president of a republic or monarch, is not responsible for political acts carried out in the exercise of its functions, although he may be called to answer for serious crimes against the State, The Roman Pontiff cannot be judged by any human authority (cf. Code of Canon Law, can. 1404: The first seat is judged by no one). Indeed, his supreme power, full, immediate and universal over the Church recognizes no higher earthly authority (cf. can. 331).
However, despite these immunities established for the protection of the office, of the Petrine ministry and his apostolic succession, the Roman Pontiff, unlike any other political figure, republican or monarchical, remains fully responsible for his actions, of his words, of their works and their omissions on the spiritual and moral level before God and before the Church. He certainly enjoys total legal immunity from men., but precisely for this reason his moral responsibility is not diminished; quite the opposite, It is increased by the singularity of his profession and by the absence of any higher earthly authority called to judge him.. This is true regardless of whether, if necessary, someone can be exposed, sacrificed or called to pay in his place. These are dynamics inherent to government policy., sometimes even in its most ruthless forms, but which lack any relevance at the doctrinal level, ecclesiological or metaphysical. Before God there are no ministerial endorsements or responsibilities transferable to others..
During the last decades that stage that I already had the opportunity to define as the era of the Pontiffs who were not informed and kept in the dark has progressively been affirmed.. In these cases, not even the former scapegoat sacrificed to save the sovereign who cannot make mistakes or be exposed for his own errors no longer pays.. Rather, responsibility tends to dissolve in a general lack of information, in news that supposedly never reached its destination, in leaked ads, incomplete or even altered by others. That this can happen occasionally is entirely plausible.. no man, not even the Roman Pontiff, possesses the gift of omniscience. It is less plausible, however, the fact that this explanation reappears with surprising regularity under different pontificates, in different times and in profoundly different circumstances. It is precisely at this point that an inevitable question arises.: if the Pontiff was not informed, who failed to inform you? If you were misinformed, who misreported it? And if he was even deceived, who deceived him? What attracts attention, when examining many cases, is that such figures almost always remain nameless, faceless and without precise identification.
Let's take an example. Suppose that within the microstate of which the Roman Pontiff is sovereign, serious and clear violations of human rights occur., precisely while he is particularly active in international politics urging governments, supranational institutions and organizations to respect the dignity of the person and the protection of fundamental rights. In cases like these, when various justification mechanisms are usually activated from time to time,: we talk about information not received, leaked news, of incomplete reports, of collaborators who supposedly did not report, of bureaucratic structures that would have hidden the truth and so on. Subjects, almost always, wrapped in vagueness, without precise name and identity.
Vladimir Putin governs a federation that spans more than seventeen million square kilometers and spans eleven time zones. Donald Trump presides over a federation that spans nearly ten million square kilometers and crosses six time zones.. Both, if they wanted it that way, could maintain with reasonable grounds that they are not in a position to know everything that happens in the most remote corners of their territories, of the various central administrations and, above all, of the peripheral. Can the same argument be invoked in the case of the Supreme Pontiff, sovereign of a State that extends for just over half a square kilometer? A state in which, to go from the Apostolic Palace to the Vatican Gardens, it is not necessary to take an intercontinental flight, cross deserts, mountain ranges or tropical jungles, much less modify the clock time to adapt to different time zones. And even in this case, It may happen that certain news undertake such long journeys, tortuous and bumpy roads that never reach their final destination.
The distance between Vatican City State and Gaza is considerable. However, This does not prevent – and rightly so – from raising our voices in defense of the tortured Palestinian people., as well as other peoples deprived of their rights in even more distant lands. It can happen, nevertheless, that this constant and justified attention to human rights violations committed thousands of kilometers away sometimes makes it more difficult to confront the various Gaza and the respective tortured Palestinians who can be found precisely within the sacred palaces of that half a square kilometer.
Is it perhaps the fault of the lack of information? Could be. ¿It's the fault of leaked news, held or never reached their destination? It can also be. everything can be. In the same way it can be, to say it in the words of the unforgettable Giuni Russo: «My mother must not know that I want to go to Alghero in the company of a foreigner» (cf. here).
One thing, however, remains beyond discussion at the doctrinal and legal level: The Roman Pontiff cannot be judged by any human authority. But perhaps precisely for this reason he is called to respond in a particular way before God for his thoughts., his words, his works and his omissions, without anyone being able to endorse his actions to exempt him from responsibility or assume, if necessary, political responsibility in place. Because if the sovereign can be protected by men, The question always remains open as to how he will be judged by Him who knows perfectly what men have seen., what they have not seen or even what they have not preferred to see. Well it is written: «To whom much was given, a lot will be required of him; and to whom much was entrusted, "even more will be asked of him" (LC 12,48).
Y, sincerely, before the divine court It will be very difficult to say that you did not know, that they had not been informed or that they had been deceived in half a square kilometer.
From the Island of Patmos, 7 June 2026
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of:
Editions The island of Patmos
n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff,
the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Padre-Ariel-foto-2025-piccola.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150father arielHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngfather ariel2026-06-08 12:10:552026-06-09 14:55:57«My mother must not know». Where the responsibility of the Pontiffs is born and dies – «My mother must not know». Where the responsibility of Pontiffs is born and where it dies – "My mother must not know". Where does the responsibility of the Pontiffs begin and where does it die??
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Padre-Ivano-piccola.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150Father IvanoHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngFather Ivano2026-06-07 17:56:202026-08-08 11:33:12Fra Nazareno da Pula: a man who wanted to please God more than men – Fra Nazarene of Pula: a man who wanted to please God more than men
GREAT HUMANITY. NOT A METAPHYSICS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: LEO XIV AND THE CUSTODY OF MAN
The problem is not how powerful Artificial Intelligence becomes, but which man uses it. Because no technique perfects what does not exist and for this reason, what is missing in man, it cannot be delegated to the machine to be created […] Civilizations begin to decline when they stop distinguishing between what can be built and what must be preserved. And of all the things man can lose, the most difficult to reconstruct is always the same: freedom.
Read the first encyclical of a Pontiff a year after the beginning of his pontificate it is always a delicate exercise, if the topic then touches on one of the most complex and controversial elements of our time: Artificial Intelligence.
The risk is twofold: on the one hand, demanding from the text what it does not want to be, on the other hand, attribute to him what he doesn't say. This methodological clarification is necessary from the beginning, Why Magnificent Humanity it was not born as a technological manifesto nor as a philosophical treatise on the nature of Artificial Intelligence. Perhaps it is precisely from here that a first impression of disorientation arises in the theologian accustomed to the great speculative encyclicals of the twentieth century.. Indeed, who expected a document built on the model of The human race, Of Development of Peoples, Of Centennial year o di Faith and Reason he might be surprised. The rest, in the magisterium of the Roman Pontiffs at least two great varieties of documents can be distinguished: texts that speak above all to the present, to the ecclesial community, to society, to politics and the urgencies of their time; texts that inevitably become dated over the years and whose main value no longer consists in offering direct answers to the problems of the present, but in allowing certain passages to be understood, crises and evolutions in the life of the Church. An example among many could be You will be surprised, given by Gregory XVI in 1832, whose sociopolitical conceptions cannot be extrapolated from that precise historical context and transposed into contemporary society. Then there are documents that, even though they were also born within a specific historical season, they mainly address issues that touch on the permanent foundations of faith and Christian anthropology and therefore continue to speak beyond their own time; think about it, with different characteristics, at the The splendor of truthof John Paul II or to Spe salvi by Benedict XVI. It is naturally still early to establish which of the two genres it belongs to Magnificent Humanity, but a first impression is that Leo XIV chose to speak to the historical present, offering orientation criteria for a transformation already underway, rather than elaborating a synthesis intended to constitute a long-term theological reference.
Leo XIV does not address the problem wondering if machines can really think, nor does it enter into the distinction between intelligence, consciousness and computation. This is perhaps a structural limit? More than a limit it seems to be the choice of a different path, outlined from the first pages: read technological transformation as a question that concerns first and foremost the vocation of man, his way of inhabiting the world and ordering his own action. From this perspective, the center of the encyclical does not appear to be Artificial Intelligence as an autonomous object of analysis, but the human subject who develops and uses it. This orientation emerges with particular clarity in chapter VI (cf.. NN. 95-99), where the August Author recalls the risk that technical efficiency is taken as the prevailing criterion for the organization of human action and insists on the fact that progress is inseparable from the formation of conscience, by personal responsibility and man's ability to direct means towards authentically human ends. Hence the insistence of the document not so much on the limits of the machine, as well as on the quality of the person who uses it. This choice also emerges in the symbolic structure of the text. In fact, the encyclical opens its reasoning through two biblical images that the Holy Father uses as a key to understanding the entire document (cf.. chapter I, NN. 8-12). The first is the story of Babel (cf.. Gen 11,1-9): men decide to build a city and a tower "whose top reaches the sky" to affirm their self-sufficiency and "make a name for themselves"; the result is not greater unity, but the confusion of languages and dispersion. The second image is that of the reconstruction of Jerusalem led by Nehemiah (cf.. Born 2-6): a destroyed city is rebuilt not to exalt someone's power, but through an orderly work, shared and oriented towards the possibility for a people to return to live and live. Through these two images the document does not contrast the technical with the non-technical, but two spiritually opposite forms of building: on the one hand the work that arises from man's self-sufficiency, from the claim to dominate the sky and from the uniformity that sacrifices the person to efficiency; on the other, patient reconstruction, shared and ordered to God, in which the common good does not arise from the power but from the responsibility of a people who mend the bonds even before the walls.
However, one question remains open which will inevitably accompany the reading of the entire text: the custody of the person and the reminder of responsibility will be sufficient to address a phenomenon that does not only concern the use of new tools, but the progressive transfer to technical apparatuses of acts that belong to knowing, to judging and deliberating proper to the person?
I. CONTINUITY AND DISCONTINUITY: THE PROBLEM IS NOT THE TECHNIQUE, BUT THE POINT FROM WHICH YOU LOOK AT IT
One of the first questions that the reader inevitably asks himself when faced with this encyclical is whether we find ourselves in continuity with the great magisterium of the twentieth century or before a document that, despite placing themselves in the same ecclesial groove, it belongs to a different level of theological construction, cultural and qualitative. The answer cannot be univocal: in terms of its fundamental contents, the text clearly fits into the continuity of the Social Doctrine of the Church. However, this does not oblige us to maintain that we are faced with a document of the same speculative depth, of the same processing capacity or the same qualitative level that characterized some great encyclicals of the last century. Recognizing this difference does not mean formulating a negative judgment on the magisterium of Leo, own sensitivity and priorities - but take note that not all magisterial documents are constructed with the same degree of speculative elaboration nor do they possess the same ability to generate theological categories destined to have a stable impact on the cultural and historical level.
Already in the introduction Leo XIV recalls the task entrusted to each generation of giving shape to its own time while safeguarding the dignity of the person, promoting justice and making brotherhood possible, reiterating that the permanent risk is that of building an inhuman world precisely at the moment in which man's ability to transform reality increases. The continuity with the previous social teaching is evident, however the observation point chosen by the text appears different. Pius XII developed his teaching through a strong work of conceptual clarification: distinguished the levels of discourse, it delimited categories and tended to build argumentative architectures in which each concept occupied a specific place. An approach supported mainly by constant comparison with the great theological tradition of the Church - from the Fathers to the Doctors - and by the classical metaphysical framework, especially in its scholastic elaboration, assumed as an instrument to safeguard the order between nature and grace, reason and faith, history and truth. Paul VI tended to read the great historical processes - economic development, social transformations, relations between peoples, modernization — trying to understand its consequences on man, on his dignity, on his freedom and on the forms of human coexistence. More than delimiting concepts, he was trying to build a vision capable of holding history together, society, personal development and vocation. John Paul II addressed the issues of his time by constantly bringing them back to the question of man. Its broad categories — person, truth, freedom, work, body, consciousness — were not presented as isolated themes, but as elements of a unitary vision in which man is understood as a moral subject called to truth and responsibility. For this reason its documents are not normally limited to indicating practical guidelines, but they tend to construct a true interpretation of man and history. Leo. A choice that emerges clearly above all in the way in which the document defines the task of discernment: not understanding how far the technique can go, but to establish towards which ends it should be oriented. An important shift ensues: the problem is not placed primarily on the level of efficiency, but on the level of human judgment. The question that remains open is not whether machines can become more intelligent, but if the man, progressively delegating acts that belong to his personal experience, still maintains control over his actions or ends up adapting to the logic of the tools he has built. For this reason the encyclical insists less on the nature of the instrument and more on the responsibility of the person who uses it. This orientation emerges with particular clarity in chapter V (cf.. n. 87), where Leo XIV states that the decisive criterion does not consist in the development of technical capacity as such, but in the question about the subject that governs it and the end to which it is ordered. So that, the decisive question, that's not what machines can do, but what man chooses to become through what he himself builds. In this sense, the document recalls that technological development cannot be evaluated exclusively on the basis of efficiency or increase in operational capabilities, but it must be judged in light of the consequences it produces on the person and on social life. The text insists that no innovation can be considered beneficial simply because it is possible or effective, but must be subjected to discernment on the human good that it is called to serve (cf.. chapter III, NN. 60-64).
However, one question remains open which will inevitably accompany the subsequent debate: whether the call to safeguard the human is sufficient or whether it becomes necessary to also question the way in which technologies modify the concrete exercise of judgment, of freedom and conscience. Therefore, whether this encyclical will have the merit of seriously reopening this question, he will have already accomplished something important.
(II). ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: GUARDING MAN OR UNDERSTANDING WHAT HE IS BECOMING?
It is probably on this point that one of the most characteristic nuclei of the encyclical is concentrated. Leo XIV does not address Artificial Intelligence starting from the question of the nature of intelligence or the possibility that artificial processes reproduce human thought. In chapter III (cf.. NN. 52-58) the document refers rather to risk than technique, as an ordered instrument for human action, progressively tends to transform into an environment capable of influencing perception, relationships and forms of experience. Subsequently, in chapter IV (cf.. NN. 71-76), addressing the issue of delegation of decision-making functions, the encyclical insists on the fact that no technical apparatus can replace personal responsibility and moral judgment. From here emerges the central point of the text: the decisive question is not what the machine can become, but what man risks to stop exercising. For this reason the document does not focus its interest on the technical description of Artificial Intelligence systems, but he repeatedly returns to the question of the human subject who designs and uses them. This orientation emerges in chapter II (cf.. NN. 28-32), where the Supreme Pontiff recalls the criterion of the dignity of the person as a measure of progress; in chapter IV (cf.. NN. 79-82), where he insists on the responsibility that accompanies every technological decision; and in chapter VI (cf.. NN. 112-116), where the common good is indicated as a criterion for judging the effects of digital transformations on social life. From this perspective, the problem is not placed primarily on the level of machine performance, but on the relationship between technical development and human responsibility.
The implicit question of the encyclical therefore seems to be: how to avoid man being reduced to a function of the system he himself has built? It is a serious and necessary question. However, right here a possible limit also emerges, or maybe, more correctly, a deliberate choice. Because the text does not seem to want to fully address an issue that today appears increasingly decisive: not just what man should guard, but what man is becoming.
The revolution of Artificial Intelligence in fact, it does not only concern new tools. It touches how we perceive time, we exercise judgment, we build relationships, we understand the body, we live freedom and form conscience. From this point of view, the problem is not simply preventing the machine from replacing man; the problem is understanding whether man, progressively entrusting increasingly larger parts of one's experience to external devices, you risk changing the very way of being a man. The encyclical approaches this question in chapter VI (cf.. NN. 103-108), when it recalls the danger of a progressive reduction of human experience to what can be measured, technically processed and administered, insisting on the fact that the person never coincides with the sum of his functions nor with the processes he is able to delegate. However, the document does not continue this line of reflection to the point of a systematic anthropological elaboration and does not enter extensively into the question of how technologies affect the structure of the cognitive act., of judgment and deliberation. His main interest remains moral and social. For this reason, the most fruitful contribution that the text can offer to the ecclesial debate does not consist so much in having said the last word on Artificial Intelligence, as in having remembered which one should remain the first: the human person. In this sense, the reference contained in chapter VII acquires particular importance (cf.. n. 124), where Leo XIV states that authentic progress does not coincide with the increase in operational capacity, but with the growth of man in responsibility and communion, remembering that no technical advancement can replace the individual's own value.
III. A FIRST CONCLUSION: BETWEEN THE CUSTODY OF MAN AND FREEDOM DENIED
It would be ungenerous to read this encyclical asking it for what it did not intend to offer. Magnificent Humanity choose another path: don't start from the question of what technique is, but by the question of which man is formed by the use of technology. We are faced with a text that chooses a different path: call the Church and the world to safeguard man in the time of digital transformation. A further question remains open - and perhaps will have to be addressed in the coming years: whether protecting man only means protecting his dignity or also understanding more deeply what is happening to his intelligence, to his freedom and his experience of reality. If this encyclical will have the merit of seriously reopening this question, he will have already accomplished something important.
Reading this encyclical I couldn't avoid a comparison with some reflections that I developed in my recent book Freedom denied(Editions The island of Patmos, January 2026), dedicated to the relationship between freedom, ethics, Artificial Intelligence and Christian anthropology. It is not a question of superimposing a personal work on the magisterium of the Roman Pontiff - but by nature, purpose and authority belongs to a completely different order - but to put two different points of observation into dialogue when faced with the same question. The encyclical chooses to address the topic starting from the Social Doctrine of the Church. This orientation emerges in particular in chapter II (cf.. NN. 28-32), where Leo. In my book I instead chose a different starting point: question the relationship between technique and the human act of knowing, judge and decide, developing this reflection in the light of the classical theological tradition and in particular the thought of Saint Thomas Aquinas. The decisive point was not whether the machine can become more efficient than man, but to ask ourselves whether there are acts specific to the person that cannot be delegated without altering the human itself. From this perspective I have taken up one of the central intuitions of the Thomistic synthesis: moral discernment arises from the unity between ratioe understanding, between the ability to analyze and that of grasping truth in its unity. Judgment does not coincide with calculation. And it is precisely here that the Thomistic principle takes on a decisive meaning. In my book I took up the famous axiom: «Grace does not destroy nature, but finish (Grace does not destroy nature, but he perfects it, QUESTION, I, I, 8 ad 2)». This principle does not state that grace replaces what man lacks; states the opposite: it brings a real nature to fruition, without eliminating or replacing it. Applied analogically to the relationship between man and Artificial Intelligence, the principle leads to a radical question: if grace perfects nature but does not replace it, can technique perfect faculties that man does not possess? The answer I have tried to develop is negative: Artificial Intelligence can amplify existing capabilities, speed up processes, support complex operations; but it cannot generate what is missing: it does not produce consciousness where there is no consciousness, it does not generate judgment where there is no moral formation, it does not create discernment where interiority is lacking.
The problem is not how powerful Artificial Intelligence becomes, but which man uses it. Because no technique perfects what does not exist and for this reason, what is missing in man, it cannot be delegated to the machine to be created. In the book I dedicated to this topic I explain that no civilization has ever collapsed because it had too powerful tools. Civilizations begin to decline when they stop distinguishing between what can be built and what must be preserved. And of all the things man can lose, the most difficult to reconstruct is always the same: freedom.
GREAT HUMANITY. NOT A METAPHYSICS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: LEO XIV AND THE CUSTODY OF MAN
The problem is not how powerful Artificial Intelligence may become, but what kind of man makes use of it. Because no technique perfects what does not exist and therefore, what is lacking in man cannot be delegated to the machine in order to be created […] Civilizations begin to decline when they cease to distinguish between what can be constructed and what instead must be safeguarded. And among all the things that man may lose, the most difficult to rebuild remains always the same: freedom.
Reading the first encyclical of a Pontiff one year after the beginning of his pontificate is always a delicate exercise, especially when the subject addressed belongs to one of the most complex and controversial territories of our time: Artificial Intelligence. The risk is twofold: on the one hand demanding from the text what it does not intend to be, on the other attributing to it what it does not say. This methodological clarification is necessary from the outset, because Magnificent Humanity was not conceived as a technological manifesto nor as a philosophical treatise on the nature of Artificial Intelligence. Perhaps it is precisely here that a first impression of disorientation arises in the theologian accustomed to the great speculative encyclicals of the twentieth century. Indeed, anyone expecting a document modelled on The human race, Development of Peoples, Centennial year or Faith and Reasonmay therefore be surprised. Moreover, within the magisterium of the Roman Pontiffs one may distinguish at least two major types of documents: texts that speak above all to the present, to the ecclesial community, to society, to politics and to the urgencies of their own time; texts which, with the passing of years, inevitably remain bound to their historical season and whose principal value no longer consists in offering direct responses to present problems but in allowing certain passages, crises and developments in the life of the Church to be understood. One example among many may be You will be surprised, issued by Gregory XVI in 1832, whose socio-political assumptions cannot be extracted from that specific historical context and mechanically transferred to contemporary society. There are then documents which, although likewise born within a precise historical season, address primarily questions touching the enduring foundations of faith and Christian anthropology and therefore continue to speak beyond their own time; one may think, with different characteristics, ofThe splendor of truth by John Paul II or Spe salviby Benedict XVI.
It is naturally still too early to establish to which of these two genres Magnificent Humanitybelongs, but a first impression is that Leo XIV has chosen to speak to the historical present, offering criteria of orientation before a transformation already underway rather than elaborating a synthesis intended to constitute a long-term theological reference. Leo XIV does not approach the problem by asking whether machines can truly think, nor does he enter into the distinction between intelligence, consciousness and computation. Is this perhaps a structural limitation?
Rather than a limitation, it appears to be the choice of a different path, outlined from the very first pages: to read technological transformation as a question concerning above all the vocation of man, his way of inhabiting the world and of ordering his own action. In this perspective, the centre of the encyclical does not appear to be Artificial Intelligence as an autonomous object of analysis, but the human subject who develops and uses it. This orientation emerges with particular clarity in Chapter VI (cf. NN. 95-99), where the Holy Father recalls the risk that technical efficiency may be assumed as the prevailing criterion for organising human action and insists that progress is inseparable from the formation of conscience, personal responsibility and man’s capacity to order means toward genuinely human ends. From this derives the document’s emphasis not so much on the limitation of the machine as on the quality of the subject who employs it. This choice also emerges in the symbolic architecture of the text. The encyclical opens its argument through two biblical images that the Holy Father uses as interpretative keys for the entire document (cf. Chapter I, NN. 8-12). The first is the account of Babel (cf. Gen 11:1-9): men decide to build a city and a tower “with its top in the sky” in order to affirm their own self-sufficiency and “make a name” for themselves; the result is not greater unity but confusion of languages and dispersion. The second image is the rebuilding of Jerusalem under Nehemiah (cf. Neh 2-6): a destroyed city is rebuilt not to exalt anyone’s power but through an ordered, shared work directed towards enabling a people once more to inhabit and live. Through these two images, the document does not oppose technology and non-technology, but two spiritually opposed forms of building: on the one hand, a work born of human self-sufficiency, of the claim to master heaven and of a uniformity that sacrifices the person to efficiency; on the other, a patient reconstruction, shared and ordered toward God, in which the common good does not arise from power but from the responsibility of a people that restores relationships before rebuilding walls.
Yet a question remains open and will inevitably accompany the reading of the entire text: whether safeguarding the person and recalling responsibility are sufficient to address a phenomenon that concerns not merely the use of new instruments but the progressive transfer to technical apparatuses of acts belonging properly to the person’s knowing, judging and deliberating.
I. CONTINUITY AND DISCONTINUITY: THE PROBLEM IS NOT TECHNOLOGY, BUT THE POINT FROM WHICH IT IS VIEWED
One of the first questions that the reader inevitably raises before this encyclical is whether we are dealing with continuity with the great magisterium of the twentieth century or with a document which, while remaining within the same ecclesial current, belongs to a different level of theological, cultural and intellectual development. The answer cannot be univocal: from the standpoint of fundamental contents, the text clearly stands in continuity with the Church’s social doctrine. Yet this does not oblige one to maintain that we are dealing with a document of the same speculative depth, the same capacity for elaboration or the same qualitative level that characterised some of the great encyclicals of the previous century. To recognise this difference does not mean to formulate a negative judgement on the magisterium of Leo XIV — each age develops its own languages, sensibilities and priorities — but to acknowledge that not all magisterial documents are constructed with the same degree of speculative elaboration, nor do they possess the same capacity to generate theological categories destined to exercise a lasting influence on the cultural and historical plane.
Already in the introduction Leo XIV recalls the task entrusted to every generation: to shape its own time while safeguarding the dignity of the person, promoting justice and making fraternity possible, reaffirming that the permanent risk is that of building an inhuman world precisely at the moment when man’s capacity to transform reality increases. Continuity with previous social magisterium is evident; nevertheless, the point of observation chosen by the text appears different. Pius XII developed his magisterium through a strong work of conceptual clarification: he distinguished levels of discourse, delimited categories and tended to construct argumentative architectures in which every concept occupied a precise place. An approach sustained principally by constant engagement with the great theological tradition of the Church — from the Fathers to the Doctors — and by the classical metaphysical framework, especially in its scholastic elaboration, assumed as an instrument to safeguard the order between nature and grace, reason and faith, history and truth. Paul VI tended to read the great historical processes — economic development, social transformations, relations among peoples, modernisation — seeking to understand their consequences for man, for his dignity, for his freedom and for the forms of human coexistence. More than delimiting concepts, he sought to construct a vision capable of holding together history, society, development and the vocation of the person. John Paul II addressed the questions of his time by constantly bringing them back to the question of man. His great categories — person, truth, freedom, work, body, conscience — were not presented as isolated themes but as elements of a unified vision in which man is understood as a moral subject called to truth and responsibility. For this reason, his documents normally do not limit themselves to indicating practical orientations but tend to construct a true interpretation of man and history. Leo XIV, by contrast, does not enter into the problem of Artificial Intelligence by asking whether computational processes can truly be considered forms of intelligence or whether calculation may replace the human act of knowing. A choice that emerges clearly above all in the way the document defines the task of discernment: not to understand how far technology may go, but to establish towards which ends it ought to be directed. From this derives an important shift: the problem is not placed first of all on the level of efficiency but on the level of human judgement. The question that remains open, therefore, is not whether machines may become more intelligent, but whether man, progressively delegating acts that belong to his personal experience, still maintains mastery over his own action or instead ends up adapting himself to the logic of the instruments he has built. For this reason the encyclical insists less upon the nature of the instrument and more upon the responsibility of the subject who uses it. This orientation emerges with particular clarity in Chapter V (cf. n. 87), where Leo XIV states that the decisive criterion does not consist in the development of technical capacity as such, but in the question concerning the subject who governs it and the end towards which it is ordered. Thus, the decisive question is not what machines are able to do, but what man chooses to become through what he builds. In this sense the document recalls that technological development cannot be evaluated exclusively on the basis of efficiency or increased operational capacities, but must be judged in light of the consequences it produces for the person and for social life. The text insists, in fact, that no innovation may be considered beneficial simply because it is possible or effective, but must be subjected to discernment regarding the human good it is called to serve (cf. Chapter III, NN. 60-64).
A question nevertheless remains open and will inevitably accompany subsequent debate: whether the appeal to safeguarding the human is sufficient or whether it becomes necessary to ask also how technologies modify the concrete exercise of judgement, freedom and conscience. Therefore, if this encyclical succeeds in seriously reopening this question, it will already have accomplished something important.
(II). ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: SAFEGUARDING MAN OR UNDERSTANDING WHAT HE IS BECOMING?
It is probably at this point that one of the most distinctive elements of the encyclical is concentrated. Leo XIV does not approach Artificial Intelligence beginning from the question concerning the nature of intelligence or the possibility that artificial processes may reproduce human thought. In Chapter III (cf. NN. 52-58), the document instead recalls the risk that technology, from being an instrument ordered to human action, may progressively become an environment capable of influencing perception, relationships and forms of experience.
Subsequently, in Chapter IV (cf. NN. 71-76), addressing the theme of delegating decision-making functions, the encyclical insists that no technical system can replace personal responsibility and moral judgement and moral judgement. From this emerges the central point of the text: the decisive issue is not what the machine may become, but what man risks ceasing to exercise. For this reason the document does not concentrate its interest on the technical description of Artificial Intelligence systems, but repeatedly returns to the question of the human subject who designs and employs them.
This orientation emerges in Chapter II (cf. NN. 28-32), where the Supreme Pontiff recalls the criterion of the dignity of the person as the measure of progress; in Chapter IV (cf. NN. 79-82), where he insists upon the responsibility that accompanies every technological decision; and in Chapter VI (cf. NN. 112-116), where the common good is presented as the criterion for evaluating the effects of digital transformations upon social life. In this perspective, the problem is not placed primarily on the level of the machine’s performance, but on the relationship between technical development and human responsibility. The implicit question of the encyclical therefore seems to be: how can man be prevented from being reduced to a function of the system that he himself has constructed? It is a serious and necessary question. Yet precisely here there also emerges a possible limitation — or perhaps, more correctly, a deliberate choice. For the text does not seem willing to confront fully a question that today appears increasingly decisive: not only what man must safeguard, but what man is becoming.
The revolution of Artificial Intelligence concerns not merely new instruments. It touches the way in which we perceive time, exercise judgement, form relationships, understand the body, live freedom and form conscience. From this point of view, the problem is not simply preventing the machine from replacing man; the problem is understanding whether man, progressively entrusting to external apparatuses increasingly extensive parts of his experience, risks modifying the very way of being human. The encyclical approaches this question in Chapter VI (cf. NN. 103-108), when it recalls the danger of a progressive reduction of human experience to what can be measured, processed and technically administered, insisting that the person never coincides with the sum of his functions nor with the processes he is capable of delegating. Yet the document does not pursue this line of reflection towards a systematic anthropological elaboration and does not enter extensively into the question of how technologies affect the structure of the cognitive act, of judgement and of deliberation. Its principal interest remains moral and social. For this reason, the most fruitful contribution that the text may offer to ecclesial debate consists not so much in having spoken the final word on Artificial Intelligence, as in having reminded us of what must remain the first: the human person.
In this sense, particular significance is acquired by the reminder contained in Chapter VII (cf. n. 124), where Leo XIV affirms that authentic progress does not coincide with the increase of operational capacity, but with the growth of man in responsibility and communion, recalling that no technological advancement can substitute the proper value of the person.
III. A FIRST CONCLUSION: BETWEEN THE CUSTODY OF MAN AND DENIED FREEDOM
It would be unfair to read this encyclical by asking from it what it did not intend to offer. We are not, in fact, before a document constructed like some of the great encyclicals of twentieth-century social magisterium, nor before a text whose task is the theoretical analysis of Artificial Intelligence in its conceptual structures, in the relationship between technology and human act, or in the consequences that automation may produce for the understanding of intelligence and freedom. Magnificent Humanity chooses another path: not to begin from the question of what technology is, but from the question of what kind of man is formed through the use of technology. We are before a text that chooses a different way: to recall the Church and the world to the safeguarding of man in the age of digital transformation. There remains open — and perhaps it will need to be addressed in the years to come — a further question: whether safeguarding man means only protecting his dignity, or also understanding more deeply what is happening to his intelligence, his freedom and his experience of reality.
If this encyclical succeeds in seriously reopening this question, it will already have accomplished something important. Reading this encyclical, I could not avoid comparing it with certain reflections I developed in my recent book “Freedom denied” (“Denied Freedom”, Editions The island of Patmos, January 2026), dedicated to the relationship between freedom, ethics, Artificial Intelligence and Christian anthropology. This is not a matter of superimposing a personal work upon the magisterium of the Roman Pontiff — which by nature, purpose and authority belongs to an entirely different order — but of placing two different points of observation into dialogue before the same question. The encyclical chooses to address the theme beginning from the Church’s social doctrine. This orientation emerges particularly in Chapter II (cf. NN. 28-32), where Leo XIV recalls that technical progress cannot be assumed as a self-sufficient criterion of development and insists that every innovation must be evaluated in the light of the good of the person and of the quality of the human relationships it contributes to generate. In my book, by contrast, I chose a different point of departure: to question the relationship between technology and the human act of knowing, judging and deciding, developing this reflection in light of the classical theological tradition and, in particular, the thought of Saint Thomas Aquinas. The decisive point was not to establish whether the machine may become more efficient than man, but to ask whether there exist acts proper to the person that cannot be delegated without altering the human itself. Within this perspective, I resumed one of the central intuitions of Thomistic synthesis: moral discernment arises from the unity between ratio and understanding, between the capacity to analyse and the capacity to grasp truth in its unity. Judgement does not coincide with calculation. And it is precisely here that the Thomistic principle acquires decisive significance. In my book I returned to the celebrated axiom: «Grace does not destroy nature, but finish (“Grace does not destroy nature but perfects it”, QUESTION, I, I, 8 ad 2)». This principle does not affirm that grace replaces what is lacking in man; it affirms the opposite: it brings a real nature to fulfilment without eliminating or replacing it. Applied analogically to the relationship between man and Artificial Intelligence, the principle leads to a radical question: if grace perfects nature but does not replace it, can technology perfect faculties that man does not possess? The answer I attempted to develop is negative: Artificial Intelligence may amplify existing capacities, accelerate processes and support complex operations; but it cannot generate what is absent: it does not produce consciousness where there is no consciousness, it does not generate judgement where moral formation does not exist, it does not create discernment where interiority is lacking.
The problem is not how powerful Artificial Intelligence becomes, but what kind of man makes use of it. Because no technique perfects what does not exist and therefore what is lacking in man cannot be delegated to the machine in order that it may be created. In the book I dedicated to this theme, I explain that no civilisation has ever collapsed because it possessed instruments that were too powerful. Civilisations begin to decline when they cease to distinguish between what can be built and what instead must be safeguarded. And among all the things that man may lose, the most difficult to rebuild has always remained the same: freedom.
Rome, 25 May 2026
.
NOT A METAPHYSICS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: LEO XIV AND THE CUSTODY OF MAN
The problem is not how powerful Artificial Intelligence becomes., but on what type of man to use it. Because no technologywas goingperfects what does not exist and, therefore, what is missing in man cannot be delegated to the machine to be created […] Civilizations begin to decline when they stop distinguishing between what can be built and what, on the contrary, must be guarded. And among all the things that man can lose, the most difficult to recover always remains the same: freedom.
Read the first encyclical of a Pontiff one year after the beginning of his pontificate, it is always a delicate exercise, especially when the topic addressed belongs to one of the most complex and controversial territories of our time.: Artificial Intelligence. The risk is twofold: on the one hand, demand from the text what it is not intended to be; on the other, attribute to him what he does not say. This methodological precision is necessary from the beginning, why Magnificent Humanity It is not born as a technological manifesto nor as a philosophical treatise on the nature of Artificial Intelligence. Perhaps it is precisely here that a first impression of confusion is born in the theologian accustomed to the great speculative encyclicals of the 20th century.. Indeed, who expected a document built according to the model of The human race, Development of Peoples, Centennial yearO Faith and Reasonyou might be surprised. Otherwise, Within the magisterium of the Roman Pontiffs, at least two major types of documents can be distinguished.: texts that speak mainly to the present, to the ecclesial community, to society, to politics and the urgencies of his own time; texts that, over the years, They inevitably become dated and whose main value ceases to consist of offering direct answers to the problems of the present and becomes a way that allows us to understand certain passages., crises and evolutions of the life of the Church. An example among many could be You will be surprised, promulgated by Gregory XVI in 1832, whose sociopolitical conceptions cannot be extrapolated from that determined historical context nor mechanically transferred to contemporary society.. Then there are, the documents that, although they were born within a certain historical period, They mainly address questions that touch on the permanent foundations of faith and Christian anthropology and, therefore, They continue to speak beyond their own time; just think, with different features: The splendor of truthof John Paul II or Spe salvi of Benedict XVI. It is still too early to establish which of these two genres it belongs to. Magnificent Humanity, but a first impression is that Leo XIV has chosen to speak to the historical present, offering guiding criteria in the face of a transformation already in progress rather than developing a synthesis intended to become a long-range theological reference.
Leo XIV does not face the problem wondering whether machines can really think nor does it fall into the distinction between intelligence, consciousness and computation. Is this a structural limit?? More than a limit, It seems to be about choosing a different path, outlined from the first pages: read technological transformation as a question that concerns above all the vocation of man, to their way of inhabiting the world and ordering their own action. From this perspective, The center of the encyclical does not seem to be Artificial Intelligence as an autonomous object of analysis, but the human subject that develops and uses it. This orientation emerges with particular clarity in chapter VI (cf. NN. 95-99), where the Augusto Author remembers the risk of technical efficiency being assumed as the predominant criterion for the organization of human work and insists that progress is inseparable from the formation of consciousness, of personal responsibility and man's ability to direct means towards authentically human ends. From this derives the document's insistence not so much on the limit of the machine, how much about the quality of the subject who uses it. This choice also appears in the symbolic structure of the text. The encyclical effectively opens its reasoning through two biblical images that the Holy Father uses as a key to reading the entire document. (cf. chapter I, NN. 8–12).
The first is the story of Babel (cf. GN 11,1-9): men decide to build a city and a tower "whose top reaches to the sky" to assert their self-sufficiency and "make a name for themselves"; the result is not greater unity, but the confusion of languages and the dispersion. The second image is the reconstruction of Jerusalem guided by Nehemiah (cf. Born 2-6): a destroyed city is rebuilt not to exalt someone's power, but through an ordered work, shared and aimed at allowing a people to return to inhabit and live. Through these two images the document does not contrast technical and non-technical, but two opposite ways of building: in the first case, the work tends to replace the good of man; in the second, remains subordinated to the good of the human community.
However, a question remains open that will inevitably accompany the reading of the entire text: If the custody of the person and the call to responsibility are enough to confront a phenomenon that does not only refer to the use of new instruments, but to the progressive transfer to technical devices of acts that belong to knowledge, the judgment and deliberation of the person.
I. CONTINUITY AND DISCONTINUITY: THE PROBLEM IS NOT THE TECHNIQUE, BUT THE POINT FROM WHICH IT IS LOOKED AT
One of the first questions that the reader inevitably asks himself when faced with this encyclical is whether we find ourselves in continuity with the great teaching of the 20th century or before a document that, even situated within the same ecclesial channel, belongs to a different level of theological construction, cultural and qualitative. The answer cannot be univocal: under the profile of the fundamental contents, The text is clearly situated in continuity with the Social Doctrine of the Church. However, This does not imply affirming that we are faced with a document of the same speculative thickness., of the same capacity for elaboration or the same qualitative level that characterized some of the great encyclicals of the last century. Recognizing this difference does not mean formulating a negative judgment about the teaching of Leo XIV — each era develops languages., own sensitivities and priorities - but to recognize that not all magisterial documents are constructed with the same degree of speculative elaboration nor do they have the same capacity to generate theological categories intended to have a stable impact on the cultural and historical level..
Already in the introduction Leo XIV remembers the task entrusted to each generation of shaping its own time while safeguarding the dignity of the person, promoting justice and making fraternity possible; reiterating that the permanent risk is that of building an inhuman world precisely at the moment when the human capacity to transform reality is increasing. The continuity with the teachings of the social teaching is evident; but the point of observation chosen by the text seems different. Pius XII developed his teaching through a strong work of conceptual clarification: distinguished the levels of discourse, It delimited the categories and tended to build argumentative architectures in which each concept occupied a precise place.. An approach sustained mainly in constant confrontation with the great theological tradition of the Church - from the Fathers to the Doctors - and by the classical metaphysical approach, especially in its scholastic elaboration, assumed as an instrument to guard the order between nature and grace, reason and faith, history and truth. Paul VI tended to read the great historical processes - economic development, social transformations, relations between people, modernization — trying to understand its consequences on man, about your dignity, about their freedom and about the forms of human coexistence. More than defining concepts, sought to build a vision capable of keeping history together, sociedad, development and vocation of the person. John Paul II faced the questions of his time by constantly returning them to the question about man. Its major categories — person, TRUE, freedom, job, body, consciousness — were not presented as isolated themes, but as elements of a unitary vision in which man is understood as a moral subject called to truth and responsibility.. That is why their documents are usually not limited to indicating practical guidelines, but rather they tend to construct a true interpretation of man and history. XIV lion, instead, does not address the problem of Artificial Intelligence by asking whether the computational process can be assimilated to intelligence or whether calculation can replace the human act of knowing.. This choice emerges clearly above all in the way the document defines the task of discernment.: not understanding how far technology can go, but to establish the purposes within which it must be oriented. This results in an important change.: The problem is not primarily at the level of efficiency, but in that of human judgment. The question that remains open is not whether machines can become smarter., but if the man, progressively delegating acts that belong to your personal experience, does he still retain control of his own work or ends up adapting to the logic of the instruments he has built. For this reason the encyclical insists less on the nature of the instrument and more on the responsibility of the subject who uses it.. This orientation emerges with particular clarity in chapter V (cf. n. 87), where Leo XIV states that the decisive criterion does not consist of the development of technical capacity as such, but in the question about the subject that governs it and the end to which it is ordered. Therefore, the decisive question is not what machines can do, but what men choose to become through that which builds. In this sense, the document recalls that technological development cannot be evaluated exclusively on the basis of efficiency or the increase in operational capabilities., but must be judged in light of the consequences it produces on the person and on social life.. The text insists, indeed, in that no innovation can be considered beneficial simply because it is possible or effective, but must be subjected to discernment about the human good that it is called to serve. (cf. chapter III, NN. 60-64).
Remains, however, open a question that will inevitably accompany the subsequent debate: if the call to the custody of what is human is sufficient or if it is also, It is necessary to question the way in which technologies modify the specific exercise of judgment, of freedom and conscience. So, whether this encyclical has the merit of seriously reopening this question, will have already done something important.
(II). ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: CUSTODY THE MAN OR UNDERSTAND WHAT HE IS BECOME?
It is probably at this point where one of the most characteristic nuclei of the encyclical is concentrated.. Leo XIV does not address Artificial Intelligence from the question about the nature of intelligence or about the possibility of artificial processes reproducing human thought.. In chapter III (cf. NN. 52-58) The document rather reminds us of the risk that technology, of an instrument ordered to human action, progressively tends to transform into an environment capable of influencing perception, relationships and forms of experience. Later, in chapter IV (cf. NN. 71-76), facing the issue of delegation of decision-making functions, The encyclical insists that no technical device can replace personal responsibility or moral judgment. From here emerges the central point of the text: the decisive question is not what the machine can become, but what man runs the risk of ceasing to exercise. For this reason, the document does not concentrate its interest on the technical description of Artificial Intelligence systems., but repeatedly returns to the question of the human subject who projects and uses them. This orientation emerges in chapter II (cf. NN. 28-32), where the Supreme Pontiff recalls the criterion of the dignity of the person as a measure of progress; in chapter IV (cf. NN. 79-82), where he insists on the responsibility that accompanies every technological decision; and in chapter VI (cf. NN. 112-116), where the common good is indicated as a criterion to judge the effects of digital transformations on social life. In this perspective, the problem is not posed primarily at the level of the machine's performance, but in the relationship between technical development and human responsibility.
The implicit question of the encyclical seems to be: How can man be prevented from being reduced to the system that he himself has built?? It is a serious and necessary question. However, precisely here emerges a possible limit - or perhaps, more correctly, a deliberate choice. Because the text does not seem to want to fully address an issue that today appears increasingly decisive.: not only what is it that man must guard, but what man is becoming.
The Artificial Intelligence revolution It is not limited only to new instruments. Affects the way we perceive time, we exercise judgment, we build relationships, we understand the body, we live freedom and form conscience. From this perspective, The problem is not simply to prevent the machine from replacing man; but in understanding if man, by progressively entrusting increasingly larger parts of their experience to external devices, runs the risk of modifying the very essence of the human being.
The encyclical approaches this question in chapter VI (cf. NN. 103-108), when he remembers the danger of a progressive reduction of human experience to that which can be measured, technically prepared and managed, insisting that the person never coincides with the sum of his functions or with the processes he is capable of delegating. However, The document does not continue this line of reflection to a systematic anthropological elaboration and does not go into the question of how technologies affect the structure of the cognitive act., of judgment and deliberation. His main interest remains moral and social.. For this reason, The most fruitful contribution that the text can offer to the ecclesial debate does not consist so much in having pronounced the last word on Artificial Intelligence., as in having remembered what must remain in the first place: the human person. In this sense, the so-called content in chapter VII takes on particular importance. (cf. n. 124), where Leo XIV affirms that authentic progress does not coincide with the increase in operational capacity, but with the growth of man in responsibility and communion, remembering that no technical advance can replace the personal value of the person.
III. A FIRST CONCLUSION: BETWEEN THE CUSTODY OF MAN AND THE DENIED FREEDOM
It would be unfair to read this encyclical demanding from him what he did not intend to offer.. Magnificent Humanity choose another path: not starting from the question about what the technique is, but from the question about what man is formed by the use of technology. We are faced with a text that chooses a different path: call the Church and the world to guard man in the time of digital transformation. A further question remains open – and perhaps will have to be addressed in the coming years.: If guarding man means only protecting his dignity or also understanding more deeply what is happening to his intelligence, with its freedom and with its experience of reality. If this encyclical has the merit of seriously reopening this question, will have already done something important.
Reading this encyclical I have not been able to avoid a dialogue with some reflections that I have developed in my recent book Freedom denied (Freedom denied, Editions The island of Patmos, January 2026), dedicated to the relationship between freedom, ethics, Artificial Intelligence and Christian Anthropology. It is not a matter of superimposing a personal work on the teaching of the Roman Pontiff - who by nature, purpose and authority belongs to a completely different order - but to establish a dialogue between two different points of observation regarding the same question. The encyclical chooses to address the issue starting from the Social Doctrine of the Church. This orientation emerges particularly in chapter II (cf. NN. 28-32), where Leo. In my book I chose, instead, a different starting point: interrogate the relationship between technology and the human act of knowing, judge and decide, developing this reflection in the light of the classical theological tradition and particularly the thought of Saint Thomas Aquinas. The decisive point was not to establish whether the machine can become more efficient than man, but to ask if there are acts specific to the person that cannot be delegated without altering the human being.. From this perspective I returned to one of the central intuitions of the Thomist synthesis: Moral discernment is born from the unity between ratio e understanding, between the ability to analyze and the ability to grasp the true in its unity. The judgment does not coincide with the calculation. And it is precisely here where the Thomistic principle acquires a decisive meaning.. In my book I took up the famous axiom: «Grace does not destroy nature, but finish (Grace does not destroy nature, but perfects it, QUESTION, I, I, 8 ad 2)». This principle does not affirm that grace replaces what man lacks.; claims exactly the opposite: complete a real nature, without removing or replacing it. Applied analogically to the relationship between man and Artificial Intelligence, the beginning leads to a radical question: If grace perfects nature, but it does not replace it, Can technology perfect faculties that man does not possess?? The answer I have tried to develop is negative.: Artificial Intelligence can amplify existing capabilities, speed up processes, sustain complex operations; but it cannot generate what is missing: does not produce consciousness where there is no consciousness, does not generate judgment where there is no moral formation, does not create discernment where interiority is lacking.
The problem is not how powerful Artificial Intelligence becomes., but on what type of man to use it. Because no technology perfects what does not exist and, therefore, what is missing in man cannot be delegated to the machine to be created. In the book that I have dedicated to this topic I explain that no civilization has ever collapsed because it had too powerful instruments.. Civilizations begin to decline when they stop distinguishing between what can be built and what, on the contrary, must be guarded. And among all the things that man can lose, the most difficult to recover always remains the same: freedom.
Rome, 25 May 2026
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of:
Editions The island of Patmos
n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff,
the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Padre-Ariel-foto-2025-piccola.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150father arielHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngfather ariel2026-05-25 13:07:182026-05-25 13:33:19Magnificent Humanity. Not a metaphysics of Artificial Intelligence: Leo XIV and the custody of man – Not a metaphysics of artificial intelligence: Leo XIV and the custody of man – Not a metaphysics of artificial intelligence: Leo XIV and the custody of man
LOVE, UNDERSTOOD AS A FEELING, IT DOES NOT HAVE A SEXUAL CONNOTATION, WORDS OF «HOMOPHOBIC PRIEST»
There is a subject who has long delighted in calling me "homophobic" and "an unresolved person obsessed with homosexuality". Those who know him have defined him as "malignant homosexual at maximum power". In response I promptly corrected and replied: «Immediately eliminate the word “homosexual” and leave only the word evil, because he would be such even if he were the most heterosexual in the entire European Union. Homosexuality, with its evil nature, it has nothing to do with it".
The worst thing a priest could do when faced with a letter like yours is a "lesson" in Catholic doctrine and morals. They exist, of course, both one and the other: Catholic doctrine and morality, but above all there is the person, understood as a creature created in the image and likeness of God.
«Even homosexuals need to love endlessly» (Father Oreste Bandi, 1925-2007)
In the Gospel, precisely referring to the observance of the law on the Sabbath, therefore in a certain sense to Jewish doctrine and morality, the Evangelist Mark refers to Jesus warning: «The Sabbath was made for man and not man for the Sabbath» (MC 2,27).
More or less we all know the teachings of the magisterium regarding sexual morality, inserted, however, in the mystery of God's grace and mercy, which requires the Church to deal first and foremost with the person, assisting her especially in moments of discouragement and weakness. For this reason we must keep Jesus' words clearly in mind: "Woe also to you, lawyers!, because you load people with burdens that are difficult to carry, and you do not touch those weights even with a finger" (LC 11,46). If you want the same concept - certainly in a different but still incisive form - we also find it in the famous ballad of the prostitute, by Fabrizio De André, where it says: «People are known to give good advice, feeling like Jesus in the temple; we know that people give good advice if they can no longer set a bad example" (Rose's Mouth, by Fabrizio De André and Gian Piero Reverberi, 1967).
The fact that you feel affection and attraction towards your friend It shouldn't upset you too much, nor let you fall into situations of discomfort and psychological suffering. Man remains largely a mystery and with him the feelings he contains within himself. At a stage of life like yours, everything is still growing, maturing, in definition: you are only a twenty year old and you are also trying to understand your emotional dimension. If to mature a dimension of emotional and sexual life it was enough to be born male or female, it would all be very simple. In reality, instead, emotional and sexual maturation requires a journey that can sometimes be long. This applies not only to people who will then experience their sexuality in concrete terms, but also for those who renounce the exercise of sexuality, such as me and my brothers, without losing the essence of virility that, before even being physical, it is psychological and remains a precious asset to be cherished for life, even when the body no longer responds to sexual impulses. On the contrary, precisely in the season of peace of mind the virility that structures the psychology of man and of the priest can be particularly enriched. In this world there are those who experience sexuality as an expression of love and those who renounce its exercise to achieve another form of love, founded not on a renunciation as an end in itself, worse on a mental castration, but on a principle of total donation. As you can see, sexuality really has many facets.
You ask me: «this affection-love that I feel for my friend, which is naturally messy...". I'll answer you clearly: an affection-love towards a friend is not disordered. Nor are you obligated to feel that affection for a girl. Affection and love, as such, you can try them for a boy, a girl, a child or an elderly person, a disabled person or a terminally ill person who is dying; you can try them for a parent or grandparent. The love, understood as a feeling, It does not have a sexual connotation. Christ does not command men to love women and women to love men: gives us a universal commandment, without distinction, saying: «My commandment is this: that you love one another as I have loved you" (GV 15,12).
What you are experiencing is first and foremost an affective experience. It is important to, so, distinguish with serenity between affection, link, need for closeness and what instead belongs to a specifically sexual dimension. Not everything intense is necessarily messy; he is often simply human and asks to be understood, polite and oriented. Don't rush to define yourself with such strict categories. You are not a label, you are not a definition: you are a person on the move. You don't have to be afraid of the good you feel, but only learn to live it in truth and freedom. And what about your friend, Don't be in a hurry to "say" or "don't say". Sometimes silence guards better than words; other times, however, a word said with simplicity and truth can clarify. However, this must be evaluated with caution, without being guided by anxiety or urgency. Meanwhile, continue your spiritual journey. The fact that you have a spiritual director is a very important thing: even if you don't get to see it often, always remains a point of reference. Inner life doesn't grow only in meetings, but also in daily faithfulness. Then, as you can see, today we have telematic tools that allow us direct and immediate contact, something unthinkable in anything but remote times, when you sent a letter that arrived after a couple of weeks and then received a response after the same amount of time.
To the question whether homosexuality is in and of itself a good thing, I have to answer no: for Catholic morality it is a sin, a disordered lifestyle. However, the tone changes completely if we move from sin to the person, or better said from sin to sinner. Sin is condemned, while the person welcomes and forgives. It is the Holy Gospel itself that clarifies it: «It is not the healthy who need a doctor, and in sickness» (Mt 9,12), says Jesus, which he specifies shortly after: «I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners ". Said this, something I invite you to do very simply: Don't fight yourself as if you were a problem to be solved. Instead, get to know yourself, to bring to light what you experience, to put him before God. The Lord is not scandalized by your effort, not even your falls. It accompanies you in your efforts, picks you up when you fall, He supports you even through the voice of a sinner like me. And I'll tell you more: the more I am aware of my being a sinner, the more I feel unworthy and, for this, a real instrument - albeit imperfect - of God's grace and mercy, who gave himself through the incarnate Word, made himself a lamb to wash, with the blood of the cross, the sins of the world.
I am a friend and confidant of many people who live their homosexuality in the sunlight, without posing any particular problems, towards whom I have always been careful not to make unsolicited moral judgments. At the same time, I am a confessor, spiritual director e, if you want, also doctor of the soul of people who do not experience certain impulses of their libido in a serene way, they keep them hidden and often suffer beyond measure. I have always told all of them that we will not be judged so much for what we have done "from the waist down", but on charity, on the love given. What the Evangelist Matthew reports is a clear warning of this, when Jesus teaches that the final judgment will be based on the concrete charity shown towards those most in need, whom we will have welcomed and treated as if they were Christ himself (cf.. Mt 25,31-46).
Dear son, I trust you that, while I was answering you, my thoughts were crossed in passing by the aggressive words of a person who has long delighted in calling me "homophobic" and "an unresolved person obsessed with homosexuality". Those who know him have defined him as "malignant homosexual at maximum power". In response I promptly corrected and replied: «Immediately eliminate the word “homosexual” and leave only the word evil, because he would be such even if he were the most heterosexual in the entire European Union. Homosexuality, with its evil nature, it has nothing to do with it".
I don't ask you for a prayer for me: I ask you for this poor unfortunate man. the, for my part, I will continue to welcome everyone, as I always have done, without asking anyone for theirs pedigreesexual, Why, if I didn't, I would betray the mission that Christ, through the Sacrament of Orders, he entrusted to me through the ministry of the Church, which implies the human and spiritual maturity to forgive the wicked, certainly not to forgive the saints.
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of:
Editions The island of Patmos
n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff,
the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Padre-Ariel-foto-2025-piccola.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150father arielHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngfather ariel2026-05-03 22:37:392026-05-03 22:37:39The love, understood as a feeling, It does not have a sexual connotation, word of "homophobic priest"
The Principality of Monaco, which has always had a privileged relationship with the Holy See, has a seat at the UN, while the Vatican is only an observer. Perhaps certain dialogues or meetings are held because they can have them, albeit silently and with soft feet, even other implications that do not tickle populism? Go and explain it to those who comment easily on social media.
When I was a young man with high hopes the only one who noticed it was a very good nun who spent much of her religious life feeding philosophy and theology students, with its kitchen. The nun envisaged a future for me as Pope. Not just a remote eventuality, but belonging to the realm of the impossible. For more, if we see what it means to be the Pope today in the time of the internet and gods social media, a career of that kind would rather be discouraged than hoped for. Newspapers or agencies give news of something the Pope has said or done? Open up heaven. Comments rain immediately, criticism and comparisons. There is someone who takes care to verify the news or evaluate it? Let's imagine. If it has already been ruminated on and prepared to be read, in case anticipated by some little title that gets likes, how do you say, the game is done. Tomorrow is another day anyway and that will be old news by now. Meantime, the flow of illiteracy that leaves no one behind continues unstoppable, even a successor of Saint Peter.
Take for example the recent trip of the Holy Father in the Principality of Monaco, The second one. But how, a Pope who goes to the kingdom of the rich, of ostentatious luxury and tax evasion? With the jarring confrontation with Francesco just around the corner, his first trip, instead he did it in Lampedusa. But if you think that even that trip was not free from criticism, you are wrong. Only now the comparison becomes useful and even good Christians fall for it, forget about that guy who was once called a glutton and a drunkard, friend of prostitutes and publicans, who didn't disdain getting help from Giovanna, wife of Cuza, Director of Herod (Mt 11,18-19; LC 8,3).
What if the Pope had gone to Munich on purpose precisely to remember what the Gospel says to those who have more than others? Easy to say in Lampedusa, try saying it in front of those who have the money, and how; with the risk of being told what the Athenians said to Paul by patting him on the shoulder: «We'll hear from you another time about this» (At 17, 32). Without the fact, not secondary, that in the Principality of Monaco there is a Catholic community which has always had a privileged relationship with the Holy See, has a seat at the UN, while the Vatican is only an observer. Perhaps certain dialogues or meetings are held because they can have them, albeit silently and with soft feet, even other implications that do not tickle populism? Go and explain it to those who comment easily on social media. They don't have time to read what the Pope said to Prince Albert II in Monaco, when he recalled that the countries of the «Mediterranean (I'm) today threatened by a widespread climate of closure and self-sufficiency". Than living in an elite place, although composite «it represents for some a privilege and for all a specific call to question their place in the world. In the eyes of God, nothing is received in vain! As Jesus suggests in the parable of the talents, what has been entrusted to us should not be buried underground, but put into circulation and multiplied in the horizon of the Kingdom of God.
This horizon is broader than the private one and it is not about a utopian world: God's Kingdom, to which Jesus consecrated his life, it's close, because he comes among us and shakes up the unjust configurations of power, the structures of sin that dig chasms between the poor and the rich, between the privileged and the discarded, between friends and enemies. Every talent, every opportunity, every good placed in our hands has a universal destination, an intrinsic need to be unrestrained, but redistributed, so that everyone's life is better. This is why Jesus taught us to pray: “Give us this day our daily bread” (Mt 6,11); and at the same time he says: «Search, first of all, the kingdom of God and his justice" (Mt 6,33). This logic of freedom and sharing is at the foundation of the parable of the Last Judgment, which has the poor at its centre: Christ the judge, who sits on the throne, he identifies with each of them (cf. Mt 25,31-46). Anyone who wants to understand should not have much effort. He reminded the Catholic community:
«Cristo […] dynamic center, heart of our faith […] His compassionate and merciful trait makes him an "advocate" in defense of the poor and sinners, certainly not to indulge evil, but to free them from oppression and slavery and make them children of God and brothers among themselves. It is no coincidence that the gestures performed by Jesus are not limited to the physical or spiritual healing of the person, but they also include an important social and political dimension: the healed person is reinstated, in all its dignity, in the human and religious community from which, often precisely because of his condition of illness or sin, had been excluded. This communion is the sign par excellence of the Church, called to be in the world a reflection of the love of God who does not show preference for people (cf. At 10,34). In this sense, I would like to say that your Church, here in the Principality of Monaco, possesses great wealth: be a place, a reality in which everyone finds welcome and hospitality, in that social and cultural mix that is your typical trait. The Principality of Monaco, indeed, it is a small state inhabited in a varied way by Monegasques, French, Italians and people of many other nationalities. A small cosmopolitan state, in which the variety of origins is also associated with other socioeconomic differences. In the Church, these differences never become an occasion for division into social classes but, on the contrary, everyone is welcomed as people and children of God, and all are recipients of a gift of grace that encourages communion, brotherhood and mutual love. This is the gift that comes from Christ, our advocate with the Father. Indeed, we have all been baptized in Him and, therefore, says Saint Paul, “there is neither Jew nor Greek; there is no slave nor free; there is no male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus". (Gal 3,28) (cf.. official speech in the video, who).
Then there was also the meeting with the young people which I omit because what I have reported is enough for me to underline that even the Petrine ministry is going through the crisis that envelops today's communication and that those who rely on the titles already set, they leave out the effort, although beautiful, to delve deeper and know.
Then there is one last aspect. Words are like seeds, they need time to germinate. In the Church quite a lot. When Benedict XV, in the midst of the First World War, defined that war: "useless massacre"; that expression, as one historian put it, «he stayed, and raised a storm". It was opposed by everyone, received with indifference by the press, by politicians and even accused of weakening the troops at the front. Today we recognize it as the most fitting definition of a tragic event and rightly consigned to history. Without that statement another Pope, Paul VI, he could not have uttered the equally famous cry in the UN assembly: «Never again war, never again war!». Today it is normal to think of popes as men of peace.
I started by mentioning the good cooking of a nun. In the same period, a few days before the conclave that would elect him began, I was mandated - I confess, without much desire - to serve Mass to Cardinal Albino Luciani, at the Church of San Marco in Piazza Venezia in Rome. We were two acolytes, the rector of the church and four cats of believers. After Mass, in the sacristy, not knowing what to say I left: "Eminence, congratulations". He looked at me good-naturedly and then said: «You know what they say in my country?». the: «no…». And he told me it in dialect and then translated it for me: «You can't make gnocchi with this pasta».
You can see that from up there someone knows how to cook better than us. It's that in the Church words are like some foods: they prefer slow and prolonged cooking, so that they can then be enjoyed in all their aromatic ranges. Today we feed on fast food, even in the news we scroll through on our smartphones. It's our time and nothing can be done about it. Maybe just remember that Guy I mentioned earlier, the one who asked for financial help from women. He once said that the Word of the Kingdom of God is like a seed that falls on different soils, some quite refractory, others more well disposed. And there it bears fruit. The divine Sower doesn't care much about the soil, but of the fruit yes, if necessary, good food too.
From the Hermitage, 30 March 2026
.
MONTECARLO AND THE YOUNG POPE COOKED BY THE NUN
The Principality of Monaco, which has always maintained a privileged relationship with the Holy See, holds a seat at the United Nations, while the Vatican is only an observer. Perhaps certain dialogues or meetings take place because they may have, even if silently and with soft steps, further implications that do not lend themselves to populist appeal? Try explaining that to those who are quick to comment on social media.
When I was a young man full of promise, the only one who seemed to notice was a very good nun who spent a large part of her religious life feeding students of philosophy and theology with her cooking. The religious sister envisaged for me a future as Pope. An eventuality not only remote, but belonging to the realm of the impossible. Moreover, if we consider what it means today to be Pope in the age of the internet and social media, such a career would be more to be discouraged than desired. Do newspapers or agencies report something that the Pope has said or done? All hell breaks loose. Comments, criticisms, and comparisons immediately pour down. Is there anyone who takes the trouble to verify the news or to examine it? Hardly. If it has already been chewed over and prepared so that it can be read, perhaps preceded by some catchy headline designed to attract likes, as they say, the game is done. After all, tomorrow is another day and that will already be old news. Meanwhile, the relentless flow of an illiteracy that spares no one continues, not even a successor of Saint Peter.
Let us take as an example the recent journey of the Holy Father to the Principality of Monaco, the second. What then, a Pope who goes to the realm of the rich, of ostentatious luxury and of tax evasion? With, just around the corner, the striking comparison with Francis who, on his first journey, went instead to Lampedusa. But if you think that even that journey was not without criticism, you are mistaken. It is only that now the comparison proves useful, and even good Christians fall into it, forgetful of that One who was once called a glutton and a drunkard, a friend of prostitutes and tax collectors, who did not disdain to be assisted by Joanna, the wife of Chuza, steward of Herod (Mt 11:18–19; Page 8:3).
What if the Pope had gone to Monaco precisely to remind those who have more than others of what the Gospel says to them? It is easy to say it in Lampedusa; try saying it in front of those who truly have money, and plenty of it, at the risk of hearing the very words that the Athenians addressed to Paul, patting him on the shoulder: “We will hear you again about this” (Acts 17:32). Leaving aside the not insignificant fact that in the Principality of Monaco there exists a Catholic community which has always maintained a privileged relationship with the Holy See, it holds a seat at the United Nations, while the Vatican is only an observer. Perhaps certain dialogues or meetings take place because they may have, even if silently and with soft steps, further implications that do not lend themselves to populist appeal? Try explaining that to those who are quick to comment on social media. They do not have the time to read what the Pope said in Monaco to Prince Albert II, when he recalled that the countries of the “Mediterranean (are) today threatened by a widespread climate of closure and self-sufficiency”. That living in an elite place, albeit a composite one, “represents for some a privilege and for all a specific calling to question their place in the world. In the eyes of God, nothing is received in vain! As Jesus suggests in the parable of the talents, what has been entrusted to us must not be buried underground, but set in motion and multiplied within the horizon of the Kingdom of God.”
That horizon is broader than the private one and does not concern a utopian world: the Kingdom of God, to which Jesus devoted his life, is near, because it comes among us and shakes the unjust configurations of power, the structures of sin that dig abysses between the poor and the rich, between the privileged and the discarded, between friends and enemies. Every talent, every opportunity, every good placed in our hands has a universal destination, an intrinsic requirement not to be withheld, but to be redistributed, so that the life of all may be better. For this reason Jesus taught us to pray: “Give us this day our daily bread” (Mt 6:11); and at the same time he says: “Seek first the Kingdom of God and his righteousness” (Mt 6:33). This logic of freedom and sharing is at the foundation of the parable of the Last Judgment, which places the poor at the center: Christ the judge, who sits on the throne, identifies himself with each one of them (cf. Mt 25:31–46). Whoever wishes to understand should not find it too difficult. To the Catholic community he recalled:
“Christ […] the dynamic center, the heart of our faith […] His compassionate and merciful disposition makes him an ‘advocate’ in defense of the poor and of sinners, certainly not in order to condone evil, but to free them from oppression and slavery and to make them children of God and brothers and sisters among themselves. It is no coincidence that the actions performed by Jesus are not limited to the physical or spiritual healing of the person, but also include an important social and political dimension: the person who is healed is reintegrated, in all his dignity, into the human and religious community from which, often precisely because of his condition of illness or sin, he had been excluded. This communion is the preeminent sign of the Church, which is called to be in the world a reflection of the love of God who shows no partiality (cf. Acts 10:34). In this sense, I would like to say that your Church, here in the Principality of Monaco, possesses a great richness: being a place, a reality in which all find welcome and hospitality, in that social and cultural mixture which is a characteristic of yours. The Principality of Monaco, in fact, is a small State, yet inhabited in a varied way by Monegasques, French, Italians and people of many other nationalities. A small cosmopolitan State, in which to the variety of origins are also joined other differences of a socio-economic kind. In the Church, such differences never become an occasion for division into social classes; on the contrary, all are welcomed as persons and as children of God, and all are recipients of a gift of grace that fosters communion, fraternity and mutual love. This is the gift that comes from Christ, our advocate before the Father. Indeed, we have all been baptized in Him and therefore, as Saint Paul affirms, ‘there is neither Jew nor Greek; there is neither slave nor free; there is neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus’” (Gal 3:28) (cf. official address in the video by Vatican News, here).
Then there was also the meeting with the young people, which I omit because what I have reported is enough for me to underline that even the Petrine ministry is traversed by the crisis that envelops contemporary communication, and that those who rely on pre-packaged headlines neglect the effort — though a beautiful one — of going deeper and of knowing.
There is then one last aspect. Words are like seeds; in order to germinate they need time. In the Church, quite a lot of it. When Benedict XV, in the midst of the First World War, defined that war as an “useless slaughter”, that expression, as a historian put it, “remained, and stirred up a storm”. It was opposed by everyone, received with indifference by the press and by politicians, and even accused of weakening the troops at the front. Today we recognize it as the most fitting definition of a tragic event, rightly consigned to history. Without that statement, another Pope, Paul VI, would not have been able to pronounce, in the assembly of the United Nations, the equally famous cry: “No more war, never again war!”. Today it is normal to think of the pontiffs as men of peace.
I began by mentioning the good cooking of a nun. In that same period, a few days before the conclave that would elect him began, I was sent — I confess, not very willingly — to serve Mass for Cardinal Albino Luciani at the Church of San Marco in Piazza Venezia in Rome. There were two of us altar servers, the rector of the church, and a mere handful of faithful. After Mass, in the sacristy, not knowing what to say, I blurted out: “Your Eminence, my best wishes.” He looked at me kindly and then said: “Do you know how we say it in my village?” I replied: “No…”. And he told me in dialect and then translated it: “With this dough, you can’t make gnocchi.”
It would seem that someone up there knows how to cook better than we do. The point is that in the Church words are like certain foods: they prefer slow and prolonged cooking, so that they may then be savored in all their aromatic layers. Today we feed on fast food, even in the news we scroll through on our smartphones. It is our time, and there is nothing to be done about it. Perhaps only to recall that One I mentioned earlier, the one who allowed himself to be supported financially by women. Once he said that the Word of the Kingdom of God is like a seed that falls on different kinds of soil, some rather resistant, others more receptive. And there it bears fruit. The divine Sower is not so concerned with the soil, but with the fruit — and, when needed, with good cooking as well.
From the Hermitage, 30 March 2026
.
MONTECARLO AND THE YOUNG POPE COOKED BY THE NUN
The Principality of Monaco, which has always maintained a privileged relationship with the Holy See, has a seat in the UN, while the Vatican is just an observer. Perhaps certain dialogues or meetings are carried out because they may have, even if it is silently and with plush steps, even other reaches that do not flatter populism? Go explain it to those who comment easily on social media
When I was a young man full of hope, The only one who seemed to notice was a very good nun who spent much of her religious life feeding philosophy and theology students with her cooking.. The nun predicted a future for me as Pope. An eventuality not only remote, but belonging to the realm of the impossible. Besides, if we consider what it means to be Pope today in times of the internet and social networks, a race of that type would be more to advise against than to wish. Do newspapers or news agencies report anything the Pope has said or done?? The sky is armed. Comments immediately rain, reviews and comparisons. Is there anyone who takes the trouble to verify the news or examine it? Don't even think about it. If it has already been ruminated and prepared to be read, perhaps preceded by some like-catching headline, as they say, the game is done. Total, Tomorrow is another day and that will be old news. Meanwhile, The flow of illiteracy that leaves no one out continues unstoppable., not even a successor of Saint Peter.
Let's take as an example the recent trip of the Holy Father to the Principality of Monaco, the second. But how is it possible?, A Pope who goes to the kingdom of the rich, of ostentatious luxury and tax evasion? With, immediately around the corner, the strident comparison with Francisco, who, on his first trip, went instead to Lampedusa. But if you think that that trip was not without criticism either, you are mistaken. Only now the comparison is useful, and even good Christians fall into it, forgetful of Him who was once called a glutton and a drinker, friend of prostitutes and publicans, who did not disdain to let Juana help, woman of Cusa, Herod's administrator (Mt 11,18-19; LC 8,3).
What would happen if the Pope had gone to Monaco? to remember what the Gospel says to those who have more than others? Easy to say in Lampedusa; try to say it in front of those who have money, and a lot; with the risk of hearing himself answer the same thing that the Athenians said to Paul, patting him on the shoulder: «We will hear from you again about this» (Hch 17,32). Leaving aside the fact, not secondary, that in the Principality of Monaco there is a Catholic community that has always maintained a privileged relationship with the Holy See, has a seat in the UN, while the Vatican is just an observer. Perhaps certain dialogues or meetings are carried out because they may have, even if it is silently and with plush steps, even other reaches that do not flatter populism? Go explain it to those who comment easily on social media. They do not have time to read what the Pope said in Monaco to Prince Albert II, when he recalled that the countries of the «Mediterranean (are) today threatened by a general climate of closure and self-sufficiency". Than living in an elite place, although composed, «represents for some a privilege and for everyone a specific call to question their own place in the world. In the eyes of God, nothing is received in vain. How Jesus makes us understand in the parable of the talents, what has been entrusted to us should not be buried underground, but put into circulation and multiplied on the horizon of the Kingdom of God.
That horizon is broader than the private one and it does not refer to a utopian world: the Kingdom of God, to whom Jesus has consecrated his life, is about, because he comes among us and shakes the unjust configurations of power, the structures of sin that open chasms between the poor and the rich, between privileged and discarded, between friends and enemies. every talent, every opportunity, Every good placed in our hands has a universal destiny, an intrinsic demand not to be held back, but redistributed, so that everyone's life is better. That is why Jesus has taught us to pray: "Give us today our daily bread" (Mt 6,11); and at the same time says: «Seek, first of all, the Kingdom of God and his justice" (Mt 6,33). This logic of freedom and sharing is at the base of the parable of universal judgment, that has the poor at the center: Christ judge, who sits on the throne, identifies with each one of them (cf. Mt 25,31-46). Whoever wants to understand should not find much difficulty. He reminded the Catholic community:
«Cristo […] dynamic center, heart of our faith […] His compassionate and merciful trait makes him a “lawyer” in defense of the poor and sinners., certainly not to support evil, but to free them from oppression and slavery and make them children of God and brothers among themselves. It is no coincidence that the gestures performed by Jesus are not limited to the physical or spiritual healing of the person., but also include an important social and political dimension: the cured person is reinstated, in all its dignity, in the human and religious community of which, often precisely because of their condition of illness or sin, had been excluded. This communion is the sign par excellence of the Church, called to be in the world a reflection of the love of God who is no respecter of persons (cf. Hch 10,34). In this sense, I would like to say that your Church, here in the Principality of Monaco, has great wealth: be a place, a reality in which everyone finds welcome and hospitality, in that social and cultural mix that is a typical feature of yours. The Principality of Monaco, indeed, It is a small inhabited state, however, variously by Monegasques, French, Italians and people of many other nationalities. A small cosmopolitan state, in which other socioeconomic differences are also added to the variety of origins. In the Church, Such differences never become an occasion for division into social classes., but, on the contrary, all are welcomed as people and children of God, and all are recipients of a gift of grace that fosters communion, brotherhood and mutual love. This is the gift that comes from Christ, our lawyer before the Father. Indeed, We have all been baptized into Him and, therefore, Saint Paul affirms, “there is no Jew or Greek; there is no slave nor free; there is no man or woman, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.". (Gal 3,28) (cf. official speech in the video, here).
Then there was also the meeting with the young people, which I omit because what I have mentioned is enough for me to emphasize that even the Petrine ministry is going through the crisis that surrounds current communication and that those who rely on already prefabricated headlines neglect the effort - although beautiful - to go deeper and to know.
There is also one last aspect. Words are like seeds: they need time to germinate. In the Church, quite. When Benedict XV, in the midst of the First World War, He defined that war as "useless slaughter", that expression, as a historian said, "it stood and raised a storm". It was fought by everyone, received with indifference by the press and by politicians, and even accused of weakening the troops on the front. Today we recognize it as the most accurate definition of a tragic event., rightly consigned to history. Without that statement, another Pope, Paul VI, would not have been able to utter the equally famous cry within the UN: «Never again war, never again war!». Today it is normal to think of the pontiffs as men of peace.
I began alluding to the good cooking of a nun. In that same period, a few days before the conclave that would elect him began, I was sent - I confess, without much desire — to serve Mass for Cardinal Albino Luciani, in the church of San Marco in Piazza Venezia, in Rome. We were the acolytes, the rector of the church and four cats of faithful. After Mass, in the sacristy, without knowing what to say, I blurted out: "Eminence, congratulations». He looked at me benevolently and then said: «Do you know how they say in my town?». Yo: «no…». And he told it to me in dialect and then he translated it for me: «Gnocchi is not made with this dough».
It seems that up there someone knows how to cook better than us.. In the Church, words are like certain foods.: They prefer slow and long cooking, so that they can then be savored in all their aromatic notes. Today we eat fast food, also in the news that we scroll through on our smartphones. It's our time and nothing can be done about it. Maybe just remember the One I mentioned before, the one who allowed himself to be helped financially by women. He once said that the Word of the Kingdom of God is like a seed that falls on different soils., some quite refractory, others more willing. And there it bears fruit. The divine Sower does not care so much about the ground, but of the fruit yes, and, when required, also good cuisine.
From the Hermitage, 30 March 2026
.
Sant'Angelo Cave in Ripe (Civitella del Tronto)
.
Visit the pages of our book shop WHO and support our editions by purchasing and distributing our books.
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of: Editions The island of Patmos n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff, the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
.
.
.
.
.
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/monaco-eremita-piccolo-.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150Hermit MonkHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngHermit Monk2026-03-31 02:09:492026-04-01 17:11:37Monte Carlo and the young Pope cooked by the nun – Montecarlo and the young Pope cooked by the nun – Monte Carlo and the young Pope cooked by the nun
BUT THE HOLY FATHER, FIRST AMONG THE USELESS SERVANTS, YOU COULD ALSO PAY ME FOR COPYRIGHTS
We have raised generations of priests who, instead of serving the Church to be nothing and nobody, they used it to become and be something and someone. Only God can read consciences and He only knows how many, today, among the marbles of the sacred palaces, they hope to become cardinals at the next consistory rather than saints. but yet, to become saints, we need to make ourselves useless, don't become cardinals: because with a purple obtained badly and used worse you risk arriving in Hell business class.
During my useless existence as a priest, it happened several times, with the Holy Father Francis of blessed memory and with the reigning Pontiff Leo XIV, of having expressed concepts - some of which even irritated some candid souls at the time - that later, years or months later, they were developed and inserted in texts of the magisterium or in pontifical speeches. Nothing exceptional: we are and remain "useless servants". This last phrase is taken from the Gospel, on which I based the homily, the 15 September 2025, at the funeral of the Apostolic Nuncio Adriano Bernardini, marking him as a "useless servant" (see who).
The journey of faith unites mystery and paradox together, as summarized by the famous expression contained in the Letter to the Hebrews: "Faith is the foundation of the things that are hoped for and the proof of those that are not seen" (EB 11,1). In this statement, which from a purely rational perspective appears contradictory, the very structure of faith is contained: it is not based on evidence, but on what exceeds the evidence; it doesn't demonstrate what you see, but it makes certain what is not seen. It is perhaps not paradoxical to be called to fulfillment precisely through the awareness of our uselessness? And yet this is precisely the point: faith does not confirm the categories of common logic, but it goes beyond them, introducing man into an order in which what appears nothing becomes the place of God's action:
«when you have done everything you were ordered to do, said: “We are useless servants. We did what we had to do "" (LC 17,10).
The first among us useless servants is Leo XIV, also called Servant of the servants of God (servant of the servants of God). Papal title assumed - we remember it incidentally - by Gregory the Great around 595, purpose, first and certainly not last, to give a thrust to the Patriarch of Constantinople, John IV known as the Faster, who had given himself the title of "ecumenical" (universal), harshly contested by Gregory the Great in his Letters (cf.. Register of Letters, V, 18; V, 20; VII, 33).
In conclusion, what it means to become and be priests? It means being nothing and no one at the service of everyone, to then reach the end of one's existence in the hope of being able to say in conscience: I tried to do my duty. But these things, in the most holy seminaries fragrant sociologisms and psychologisms, Unfortunately they haven't taught them for a long time. This is also why we have raised generations of priests who, instead of serving the Church to be nothing and nobody, they used it to become and be something and someone. Only God can read consciences and He only knows how many, today, among the marbles of the sacred palaces, they hope to become cardinals at the next consistory rather than saints. but yet, to become saints, we need to make ourselves useless, don't become cardinals: because with a purple obtained badly and used worse you risk arriving in Hell business class.
Yesterday's news was that the Useless Servant Leo XIV gave a speech that sounds obvious to me, although today, Unfortunately, it is precisely the most obvious obviousness that is not accepted and understood. The Holy Father reminded the French Bishops gathered in Lourdes of our mandatory obligation to think of the victims of pedophilia but, at the same time, to show mercy to the priests guilty of this terrible crime:
«continue to demonstrate the Church's attention towards the victims and God's mercy towards everyone. It is good that priests guilty of abuse are not excluded from this mercy and are the object of your pastoral reflections" (Vatican News, who).
Unfortunately, in recent years, even within the Church we have sometimes succumbed to the same worldly logic, taking on expressions and criteria typical of the squares driven by gallows emotion. After the serious scandals that have involved and often overwhelmed various members of our clergy - scandals that canon law properly defines serious offenses — has begun to be used, even at the highest levels, a formula that sounds like an insult to the Christian faith: «zero tolerance». Such a language, borrowed from political and media lexicon, it reveals a mentality foreign to the Gospel and the penitential tradition of the Church. It is obvious that when faced with certain crimes - such as sexual abuse of minors - the perpetrator must be immediately neutralized and placed in a position to no longer harm, therefore subjected to a just punishment, proportionate and, according to canonical doctrine, MEDICAL, that is, oriented towards its recovery and conversion. This is why the expression "zero tolerance" is aberrant on a doctrinal and pastoral level, because it does not belong to the language of the Church, but to that of populist campaigns that focus and play on the belly moods of the masses.
Declaring that those who need a doctor are the sick and not the healthy (cf.. Mt 9, 12), Jesus indicates and entrusts us with a specific mission, does not invite us to "zero tolerance".
Faced with these new trends a paradoxical moral short circuit emerges: the same consciences that for years have hidden the dirt under the carpets with rare and silenced clerical malice, today they are zealous in publicly proclaiming their severity, almost as if to purify themselves before the world. Sometimes innocent people or simply suspects are hit to demonstrate rigor, while the real culprits - in other times protected - often go unpunished and, sometimes, promoted to the highest ecclesial and ecclesiastical leaders, because it is precisely there that we find them all "to judge the living and the dead", almost as if their reign - that of falsehood and hypocrisy - "will never end", in a sort of backwards Creed. All this is presented as evidence of a "new Church" that would finally embrace the politics of firmness. And the much vaunted mercy, where have you been? If we go and see we will discover that in order to benefit from mercy it seems it is necessary to be black who commits violence in the most central areas of cities, including attacks on the police themselves, despite being promptly justified, they do not commit crimes because they are violent and inclined to crime, but due to society being strictly guilty of not having adequately welcomed and integrated them. Let's ask ourselves: what credibility can an evangelical announcement have that preaches mercy only for certain "protected categories" and at the same time adopts the logic of the so-called "zero tolerance" for those, within itself, he was seriously wrong? It is here that the most dramatic outcome of internal secularization manifests itself: the Church that to please the world renounces the language of redemption to take on that of gallows revenge, showing mercy only with what corresponds to the social tendencies of political correctness (previous full article who).
Reasonably, I could also claim the copyright from the Holy Father; but I am modest and settle for much less: it would be enough for me that certain subjects, clerical and lay, both active and uncontrolled, functional to a specific system and tolerated within his own home, leave this useless servant alone, who only wants to be able to say about his existence at the end: I did what I had to do.
HOWEVER, THE HOLY FATHER, FIRST AMONG USELESS SERVANTS, COULD ALSO PAY ME COPYRIGHT FEES
We have formed generations of priests who, instead of serving the Church in order to be nothing and nobody, have used her in order to become something and someone. Only God can read consciences, and He alone knows how many, today, among the marbles of the sacred palaces, hope to become cardinals at the next consistory rather than saints. Yet, to become saints one must make oneself useless, not become a cardinal: because with a purple obtained badly and used even worse, one risks arriving in Hell in business class.
In the course of my useless existence as a priest, it has happened several times, both with the Holy Father Francis of blessed memory and with the reigning Pontiff Leo XIV, that I expressed concepts — some of which initially irritated even certain candid souls — which were later developed and incorporated into magisterial texts or papal discourses. Nothing exceptional: we are and remain «useless servants». This expression is taken from the Gospel, and it was precisely on it that I based my homily on 15 September 2025 at the funeral of the Apostolic Nuncio Adriano Bernardini, referring to him as a «useless servant» (see here).
The journey of faith unites mystery and paradox, as summarized in the well-known expression contained in the Letter to the Hebrews: «Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen» (Heb 11:1). In this affirmation, which appears contradictory to a purely rational gaze, lies the very structure of faith: it is not grounded in evidence, but in what exceeds evidence; it does not demonstrate what is seen, but makes certain what is not seen. Is it not paradoxical to be called to fulfillment precisely through the awareness of our uselessness? And yet this is precisely the point: faith does not confirm the categories of common logic, but surpasses them, introducing man into an order in which what appears to be nothing becomes the place of God’s action:
«when you have done all that you were commanded, say: “We are useless servants; we have done what we were obliged to do”» (Page 17:10).
The first among us useless servants is Leo XIV, also called Servant of the servants of God (servant of the servants of God). This papal title was assumed — let it be recalled in passing — by Gregory the Great around 595, primarily, though not exclusively, as a rebuke to the Patriarch of Constantinople, John IV known as the Faster, who had attributed to himself the title «ecumenical», strongly contested by Gregory the Great in his Letters (cf. Register of Letters, V, 18; V, 20; VII, 33).
Ultimately, what does it mean to become and to be a priest? It means to be nothing and nobody in the service of all, so as to arrive at the end of one’s existence with the hope of being able to say in conscience: I have tried to do my duty. But these things, in the most “holy” seminaries reeking of sociologism and psychologism, have not been taught for a long time. For this reason as well, we have formed generations of priests who, instead of serving the Church in order to be nothing and nobody, have used her in order to become something and someone. Only God can read consciences, and He alone knows how many, today, among the marbles of the sacred palaces, hope to become cardinals at the next consistory rather than saints. Yet, to become saints one must make oneself useless, not become a cardinal: because with a purple obtained badly and used even worse, one risks arriving in Hell in business class.
It is news of yesterday that the Useless Servant Leo XIV delivered a discourse which to me sounds obvious, although today, unfortunately, it is precisely the most evident obviousness that is neither received nor understood. The Holy Father reminded the French bishops gathered in Lourdes of our inescapable duty to think of the victims of pedophilia and, at the same time, to exercise mercy toward priests guilty of this immense crime:
«continue to show the Church’s attention toward the victims and the mercy of God toward all. It is good that priests guilty of abuse are not excluded from this mercy and are the object of your pastoral reflections» (Vatican News, here).
After my book dedicated to the historical-theological explanation of the profession of faith, Credo per capire – Journey into the Profession of Faith, published on 15 November 2025, a second book followed on 29 January: La libertà negata – Catholic Theology and the Dictatorship of Western Conformism. In this second book I also address the delicate topic treated by the Holy Father, which I had already taken up in an article dated 16 November 2025 (see here). On this very delicate subject I developed a reflection which I reproduce here in full:
Unfortunately, in recent years, even within the Church there has at times been a yielding to this same worldly logic, adopting expressions and criteria proper to squares moved by a lynch-mob emotionality. After the grave scandals that have involved — and often overwhelmed various members of our clergy — scandals that canon law properly defines as serious offenses, a formula has begun to be used, even at the highest levels, which sounds like an insult to the Christian faith: “zero tolerance.” Such language, borrowed from the political and media lexicon, reveals a mentality foreign to the Gospel and to the Church’s penitential tradition. It is obvious that in the face of certain crimes — such as sexual abuse of minors — the perpetrator must be immediately neutralised and placed in the condition of no longer being able to cause harm, and therefore subjected to a punishment that is just, proportionate and, according to canonical doctrine, medicinal, that is, directed to his recovery and conversion. For this reason, the expression “zero tolerance” is aberrant on the doctrinal and pastoral plane, because it does not belong to the language of the Church, but to that of populist campaigns that aim at and play upon the gut instincts of the masses.
By declaring that it is the sick and not the healthy who are in need of a physician (cf. Mt 9:12), Jesus indicates and entrusts to us a precise mission; He does not invite us to “zero tolerance.”
Before these new tendencies, a paradoxical moral short circuit emerges: the very same consciences that for years have hidden the filth under the carpets with rare and conspiratorial clerical malice now show themselves zealous in publicly proclaiming their severity, as though purifying themselves before the world. At times the innocent, or the merely suspected, are struck down in order to demonstrate rigour, while the true guilty — once protected — often remain unpunished and, at times, are promoted to the highest ecclesial and ecclesiastical positions, for it is precisely there that we find them all, “to judge the living and the dead,” almost as though their kingdom — the kingdom of falsehood and hypocrisy — “will have no end,” in a kind of inverted Creed. All this is presented as proof of a “new Church” that would at last have embraced the politics of firmness.
And what of the much-vaunted mercy, what has become of it? If we look closely, we shall discover that, in order to be able to benefit from mercy, it seems necessary to be black people who commit acts of violence in the most central areas of the cities, including assaults against the very Forces of Order, yet who are promptly justified, not because they do not commit crimes, but because, being violent and inclined to delinquency, it is said that they act on account of a society strictly guilty of not having adequately welcomed and integrated them.
Let us ask ourselves: what credibility can a Gospel proclamation have that preaches mercy only for certain “protected categories” and at the same time adopts the logic of so-called “zero tolerance” towards those who, within its own ranks, have gravely erred? It is here that the most dramatic outcome of internal secularisation is manifested: the Church which, in order to please the world, renounces the language of redemption to assume that of lynch-mob vengeance, showing herself merciful only with that which corresponds to the social tendencies of political correctness.
Reasonably, I could also claim copyright from the Holy Father; but I am modest and content myself with much less: it would suffice for me that certain subjects, clerical and lay, as active as they are uncontrolled, functional to a precise system and tolerated within his very house, would leave this useless servant in peace, who desires only to be able to say, at the end of his existence: I have done what I had to do.
From the Island of Patmos, 26 March 2026
.
THE HOLY FATHER, FIRST AMONG THE USELESS SERVANTS, YOU COULD ALSO PAY ME THE COPYRIGHTS
We have formed generations of priests who, instead of serving the Church to be nothing and nobody, They have used it to become something and someone. Only God can read consciences, and only He knows how many, hoy, among the marbles of the sacred palaces, They hope to become cardinals in the next consistory instead of saints. Y, however, To become saints it is necessary to become useless, not become cardinals: because with a purple obtained badly and used worse, there is a risk of reaching Hell in business class.
Throughout my useless existence as a priest, It has happened on several occasions, both with the Holy Father Francis of blessed memory and with the reigning Pontiff Leo XIV, that I have expressed concepts — some of which irritated even certain candid souls at the time — that have subsequently been developed and incorporated into texts of the magisterium or in pontifical speeches. Nothing extraordinary: We are and continue to be "useless servants". This expression comes from the Gospel, and precisely on it I based my homily of the 15 September of 2025 at the funeral of the Apostolic Nuncio Adriano Bernardini, referring to him as a "useless servant" (see here).
The path of faith unites mystery and paradox, as summarized by the famous expression contained in the Letter to the Hebrews: "Faith is the foundation of things hoped for and proof of things not seen." (Hb 11,1). In this statement, that from a purely rational perspective appears contradictory, the very structure of faith is contained: not based on evidence, but in that which exceeds the evidence; does not show what is seen, but makes certain what is not seen. Is it not paradoxical to be called to fulfillment precisely through the awareness of our uselessness?? Y, however, this is precisely the point: faith does not confirm the categories of common logic, but it surpasses them, introducing man into an order in which what seems like nothing becomes the place of God's action:
«when you have done everything that was commanded you, DECIDED: “We are useless servants; "We have done what we had to do." (LC 17,10).
The first among us useless servants is Leo XIV, also called Servant of the servants of God (servant of the servants of God). This pontifical title was assumed - it is worth remembering - by Gregory the Great around the year 595, mainly, although not exclusively, as a correction addressed to the Patriarch of Constantinople, John IV called the Faster, who had attributed the title of "ecumenical", strongly contested by Gregory the Great in his Letters (cf. Register of Letters, V, 18; V, 20; VII, 33).
deep down, What does it mean to become and be a priest?? It means being nothing and nobody at the service of everyone, to be able to reach the end of one's existence with the hope of being able to say in conscience: I have tried to do my duty. but these things, in the most holy seminaries impregnated with sociologisms and psychologisms, Unfortunately they have not been taught for a long time.. That is why we have also formed generations of priests who, instead of serving the Church to be nothing and nobody, They have used it to become something and someone. Only God can read consciences, and only He knows how many, hoy, among the marbles of the sacred palaces, They hope to become cardinals in the next consistory instead of saints. Y, however, To become saints it is necessary to become useless, not become cardinals: because with a purple obtained badly and used worse, there is a risk of arriving in Hell in business class. It is yesterday's news that the Useless Servant Leo XIV He has given a speech that is obvious to me, although today, unfortunately, It is precisely the clearest evidence that is not accepted or understood. The Holy Father reminded the French bishops gathered in Lourdes of our unavoidable duty to think about the victims of pedophilia and, at the same time, to exercise mercy towards the priests guilty of this immense crime:
«Continue to express the attention of the Church towards the victims and the mercy of God towards all. "It is good that priests guilty of abuse are not excluded from this mercy and are the object of your pastoral reflections." (Vatican News, here).
after my book dedicated to the historical-theological explanation of the profession of faith, Credo per capire – Journey in the profession of faith, published on 15 November 2025, he 29 January followed by a second book: Freedom Denied – Catholic Theology and the Dictatorship of Western Conformism. In this second book I also address the delicate topic discussed by the Holy Father, which I had already taken up in an article in the 16 November 2025 (see here). On this very delicate topic I developed a reflection that I reproduce below in its entirety.:
Unfortunately, in recent years, even within the Church we have sometimes given in to the same worldly logic, adopting expressions and criteria typical of the squares moved by the emotionality of lynching. Following the serious scandals that have implicated and often devastated several members of our clergy—scandals that canon law properly defines as sERIOUS oFFENSES —, has started to be used, even at the highest levels, a formula that sounds like an insult to the Christian faith: "zero tolerance". A similar language, taken from the political and media lexicon, reveals a mentality alien to the Gospel and the penitential tradition of the Church. It is obvious that in the case of certain crimes - such as sexual abuse of minors - the perpetrator must be immediately neutralized and placed in the condition of not being able to do more harm., and therefore subjected to a just penalty, provided and, according to canonical doctrine, medicinal, that is to say, aimed at recovery and conversion. For this reason, The expression “zero tolerance” is aberrant on a doctrinal and pastoral level., because it does not belong to the language of the Church, but that of populist campaigns that target and play with the viscera of the masses.
By declaring that those who need a doctor They are the sick and not the healthy (cf. Mt 9,12), Jesus tells us and entrusts us with a precise mission, does not invite us to "zero tolerance".
Given these new trends a paradoxical moral short circuit arises: the same consciences that for years have hidden dirt under the rugs with rare and omertous clerical malice today are jealous by publicly proclaiming its severity, almost as if to purify oneself before the world. Sometimes the innocent or the simply suspicious are beaten to demonstrate rigor., while the real culprits - once protected - usually go unpunished and, sometimes, are promoted to the highest ecclesiastical and ecclesiastical positions, because that is precisely where we find them all, "to judge the living and the dead", almost as if his kingdom — that of falsehood and hypocrisy — “had no end”, in a sort of backwards Creed. All this is presented as proof of a "new Church" that would have finally embraced the policy of firmness.
And the mercy so decanted, what has become of her? If we are going to see, We will discover that in order to benefit from mercy it seems necessary to be black people who commit violence in the most central areas of cities., including attacks on the Law Enforcement Forces themselves, and yet readily justified, not because they don't commit crimes, but because, being violent and prone to crime, It is stated that the blame falls on a society rigorously guilty of not having welcomed and integrated them properly.. let's ask ourselves: What credibility can an evangelical advertisement have that preaches mercy only for certain “protected categories” and at the same time adopts the logic of so-called “zero tolerance” for those who, in your own bosom, han seriously wrong? Here the most dramatic result of internal secularization is manifested: the Church that, to please the world, renounces the language of redemption to assume that of revenge for lynchings, showing mercy only with that which corresponds to the social tendencies of political correctness.
Reasonably, You could even claim the copyright from the Holy Father; but I am modest and I settle for much less: It would be enough for me that certain subjects, clerical and lay, as active as uncontrolled, functional to a precise system and tolerated within your own home, They will leave this useless servant alone, you just wish you could say, at the end of its existence: I have done what I had to do.
From the Island of Patmos, 26 March 2026
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of:
Editions The island of Patmos
n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff,
the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Padre-Ariel-foto-2025-piccola.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150father arielHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngfather ariel2026-03-26 16:32:342026-03-26 18:00:28But The Holy Father, first among the useless servants, he might even pay me royalties – However, the Holy Father, first among useless servants, could also pay me copyright fees – The Holy Father, first among useless servants, could you also pay me the copyright
The Church can give the blessing, even among a thousand distinctions, also to those experiencing exceptional situations, particular or irregular. Particularly if these people are baptized in communion with the Church, even if they live in a vital situation that the Church considers wrong.
The statementBegging for Confidence, dating back to December 2023, it concerned the possibility of blessing irregular and even same-sex couples.
Monica Bellucci in the role of Maddalena (The Passion, 2004)
The receipt thereof, immediately, must have elicited conflicting responses from the episcopate if already in January of the following year the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith felt the need to issue a press release with clarifications regarding the simple nature, informal and pastoral of the aforementioned blessings, without creating confusion with the doctrine regarding marriage and normal ritualized liturgical blessings. In the same context, mention was made of the possibility of a gradual acceptance of the Declaration or even its non-reception in the most delicate and difficult cases. However, its value was advocated, as an opportunity to listen to the requests that arise from the faithful and to offer them appropriate catechesis in this regard.
At the end of an article that appeared in this magazine of ours, in which the topic of homosexuality and the Bible was discussed (Who), it was hoped that the path of reflection on these issues would not be abandoned. With this writing, despite its brevity and inadequacy of the author, I would like to continue the task, answering the question whether it is right to give a spiritual good of the Church, how can it be a blessing, also to those who live in situations that we could define as particular, which constitutes an exception, if you really want to avoid the recurring term that refers to irregularity, starting from or extending what the Church already does in other situations.
In the Code of Canon Law of the Catholic Church we talk about the theme of intercommunion with separated brothers, especially the fee 844 addresses the topic concerning the administration of the Sacraments by a minister of the Church to the faithful who do not have full communion with the Catholic Church, the so-called Communication in the sacred. The text takes into consideration two categories of non-Catholic Christians: the «members of the Eastern Churches» (§ 3) and the "other Christians", that is, those belonging to Western Christian confessions, that is, those that have existed in the West since the time of the Reformation (§ 4). For both categories of Christians the text of the code states that «Catholic ministers lawfully administer the sacraments of penance, of the Eucharist and the anointing of the sick" (§§ 3-4). The same canon reiterates that both categories of Christians "do not have full communion with the Catholic Church" (§§ 3-4); which means - said positively - that these Christians are in true communion with the Catholic Church, even if not full (cf.. above all The light, n. 15; Reintegratio, NN. 3,1; 22,2).
More specifically the fee 844, § 4 demands that there must be a serious and urgent need for the administration of the Sacraments by the Catholic Church to non-Catholic Christians belonging to Western Confessions. However, the encyclical To be one, to the number 46 he also speaks of the existence of "special cases" e Church of the Eucharist, to the number 45, also mentions "special circumstances". Since the Code of Canon Law depends essentially on the Second Vatican Council, one cannot fail to mention what is the most important text on this topic, that is Reintegratio, all no. 8, which is thus expressed: «Intercommunion (in the Sacraments, n.d.r.) It depends above all on two principles: from the manifestation of the unity of the Church and from participation in the means of grace". The manifestation of unity mostly prohibits intercommunion. The participation of grace, the grace to be procured, sometimes he recommends it. Naturally the first principle serves to safeguard ecclesial communion and therefore the danger of error or indifferentism is avoided, as if administering the Sacraments to Catholics and to those who are not were the same thing, because such is not, without penalty of misunderstanding. Therefore, believing that there is no difference between being or not being in communion with the Catholic Church would lead to disorientation and scandal.. On the other hand - and I recall here the words of Cardinal Francesco Coccopalmerio, president emeritus of the Pontifical Council for Legal Texts —:
«The second principle recalls the need to confer grace on the part of the Catholic Church and not in just any way, but rather specifically through the administration of the Sacraments. And this applies not only to Catholic Christians, but for all the baptized, even for non-Catholics. This is the great teaching stated with clarity and conviction by the great text of Vatican II. Let's realize this carefully: Non-Catholic Christians have a spiritual need to receive the conferral of grace through the administration of the Sacraments. They therefore have the spiritual need to receive the Sacraments. We can also say that non-Catholic Christians have the right to receive the Sacraments. And the Catholic Church has the duty to administer the Sacraments to these Christians. We can consider all this as a simple determination of the principle of grace to be procured, where the gerund is noted as a sign of necessity" (edited by Andrea Tornielli, Who).
Taking the reasoning to the end, when asked if a married couple, one Catholic and the other not in full communion with the Church, by participating together in the Holy Mass they also wish to receive the Eucharist, this can be considered an exceptionality, if this corresponds to a spiritual need of the spouses who would otherwise experience that moment separately or not at all, abstaining from it; the expert Prelate responds thus:
«If the Catholic minister administered Holy Communion to the non-Catholic spouse, everyone could reasonably believe that this concession is determined by the just need not to separate a married couple, especially in such a special moment as participation in the sacrament of the Eucharist. All this can, Anyway, always be recalled through an explanatory catechesis given to the community of the faithful even on a recurring basis".
I don't want to dwell too much on this topic any longer, also because the focus, as mentioned initially, it's another. Many other things could be said because the topic is still studied and explored and I haven't mentioned it, just so I don't get too long, to the previous conditions or spiritual and mental dispositions that must be present in someone, even if not in full communion, the Church can, in specific and exceptional cases, receive the sacraments of grace from a Catholic minister. It is also clear that all this belongs to an area strictly regulated by Church law and cannot in any way be confused with forms of indiscriminate intercommunion or, worse, with Eucharistic celebrations that ignore full ecclesial communion and the validity of the priestly ministry. Precisely because it is a delicate matter, the reference to exceptional cases must never be taken as an ordinary criterion, but as confirmation of the fact that the Church, while firmly guarding the meaning of its spiritual goods, he never ceases to wonder how to obtain them, in permitted cases, for the salvation of all souls.
As you can imagine, all this reasoning that from the Council then landed in the Code, arises both from theological reflection on the spiritual goods of the Church which in themselves want to be lavished in abundance and can hardly be denied to those who trust, he asks for respect and good disposition, both from not being able to deny that the human situations that people experience in this world are multiple and varied. And the Church, which guards the treasures of divine grace, he can only wonder about this.
Returning then to the topic that started this writing, the answer can only be positive. The Church can give the blessing, even among a thousand distinctions, also to those experiencing exceptional situations, particular or irregular. Particularly if these people are baptized in communion with the Church, even if they live in a vital situation that the Church considers wrong. If they can, under the appropriate conditions, receive the Sacraments like all other baptized people e, we saw it, even those who belong to another confession and are unable to contact their ministers can do so, why not even a simple blessing that would only serve to reiterate what the Church has always done: reject sin, but to welcome and love the sinner, as the Lord taught? However, it remains necessary to clarify that such a blessing could never be correctly understood as confirmation, ratification or legitimization of the objective condition in which these people find themselves. If so, both the meaning of the blessing and the very truth of ecclesial pastoral care would be betrayed. The church, indeed, can bless the person who asks God for help, not sin as such, nor the claim that a situation contrary to his doctrine is thereby recognized as morally good or ecclesially legitimate. Precisely for this reason the blessing, if requested with faith and humility, it retains its meaning only if it remains a gesture of invocation, of trust and accompaniment, never of implicit consecration of a condition of life.
As the prefect of the Dicastery specified at the time for the Doctrine of the Faith in the press release referred to above, the purpose of the Declaration that, it must be admitted, someone had a bad stomach, was to highlight the value of the blessing for the Church, in order to arrive at a "broader understanding of the blessings and the proposal to increase pastoral blessings, which do not require the same conditions as blessings in a liturgical or ritual context".
No longer living in a Christianized context for a long time, the Church will increasingly encounter situations that are not regular according to doctrine. It will be able to entrench itself in a defensive position and simply take refuge behind the doctrine that recognizes the illicit nature of some human conditions, but that wouldn't say anything new about it. Or, following the example of his Master, will be able to recognize that a relationship is wrong, yet it preserves within it positive elements that cannot be denied and therefore why not pour on these situations "the oil of consolation and the wine of hope", even a simple informal blessing where requested with confidence? Also here, however, discernment remains decisive: it is one thing to pastorally help people who, even in an objectively disordered or irregular condition, they ask for spiritual help without claiming any legitimacy; it would be another thing to endorse, even if only indirectly, the claim that ecclesial welcome coincides with the recognition of their status as compliant with the Gospel. The mercy of the Church does not consist in obscuring the truth, but in accompanying people towards it with patience, without rejecting and humiliating anyone, but at the same time without distorting anything.
here it is, so, a small contribution to the reflection which has no pretensions, moved only by that spirit that lies behind Jesus' invitation to be a disciple "similar to a householder who extracts new and old things from his treasure" (Mt 13,52). For this, the Church's task is neither to close the door of grace to those who ask for it with sincere trust, nor confuse mercy with the legitimation of what remains contrary to the Gospel, but to safeguard truth and charity together, so that every pastoral gesture is an authentic help for people and never an occasion for misunderstanding regarding doctrine. All of this, without ever losing sight of the very essence of the mission entrusted to us by Christ with precise words:
«It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. Go and learn what this means: I desire mercy, not sacrifice. For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners " (Mt 9, 12-13).
From the Hermitage, 19 March 2026
.
THE VARIOUS FACETS OF BLESSING
The Church can grant a blessing, albeit with many distinctions, even to those who live in exceptional, particular or irregular situations. Especially if these persons are baptized in communion with the Church, even if they live in a life situation that the Church considers erroneous.
The DeclarationBegging for Confidence, issued in December 2023, concerned the possibility of blessing irregular couples and even same-sex couples. Its reception, at least initially, must have elicited contrasting responses within the episcopate, if already in January of the following year the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith felt the need to issue a press release with clarifications regarding the simple, informal and pastoral character of such blessings, so as not to create confusion with the doctrine concerning marriage and with the ordinary ritual liturgical blessings. In the same context, reference was made to the possibility of a gradual acceptance of the Declaration or even to its non-reception in the most delicate and difficult cases. Nevertheless, its value was encouraged, as a way of remaining attentive to the requests arising from the faithful and of offering them an appropriate catechesis on the matter.
Toward the end of an article published in this same journal, which dealt with the theme of homosexuality and the Bible (Here), the hope was expressed that the path of reflection on these themes would not be abandoned. With the present text, despite its brevity and the inadequacy of its author, I would like to continue this task by responding to the question of whether it is right to grant a spiritual good of the Church, such as a blessing, even to those who live in a situation that we might define as particular — an exception, if one wishes to avoid the recurring term that refers to irregularity — starting from, or extending, what the Church already does in other situations.
In the Code of Canon Law of the Catholic Church the question of intercommunion with separated brethren is addressed; in particular, canon 844 deals with the administration of the Sacraments by a minister of the Church to the faithful who are not in full communion with the Catholic Church, the so-called Communication in the sacred. The text considers two categories of non-Catholic Christians: the “members of the Eastern Churches” (§ 3) and “other Christians,” that is, those belonging to Western Christian confessions, namely those existing in the West since the time of the Reformation (§ 4). For both categories the canonical text states that “Catholic ministers administer licitly the sacraments of penance, the Eucharist and the anointing of the sick” (§§ 3–4). Concerning both categories the same canon reiterates that they “are not in full communion with the Catholic Church” (§§ 3–4); which means — stated positively — that these Christians are in a true, though not full, communion with the Catholic Church (cf. especially The light, n. 15; Reintegratio, NN. 3,1; 22,2).
More specifically, canon 844 § 4 requires that for the administration of the Sacraments by the Catholic Church to non-Catholic Christians belonging to Western confessions there must be a grave and urgent necessity. However, the encyclical To be one, in no. 46, also speaks of the existence of “particular cases,” and Church of the Eucharist, in no. 45, likewise refers to “special circumstances.” Since the Code of Canon Law depends essentially on the Second Vatican Council, one cannot fail to mention what is the most important text on this subject, namely Reintegratio, no. 8, which states: “The sharing in the Sacraments (Communication in the sacred) depends chiefly on two principles: the manifestation of the unity of the Church and the sharing in the means of grace.” The manifestation of unity generally forbids intercommunion. The sharing in grace, the they procure graceit gives, sometimes recommends it. Naturally, the first principle serves to safeguard ecclesial communion and to avoid the danger of error or indifferentism, as if administering the Sacraments to Catholics and to those who are not were the same thing, which it is not, without giving rise to misunderstanding. To maintain that there is no difference between being or not being in communion with the Catholic Church would lead to confusion and scandal. On the other hand — and I recall here the words of Cardinal Coccopalmerio, emeritus president of the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts —:
“The second principle recalls the necessity for the Catholic Church to confer grace not in just any way, but in a specific way through the administration of the Sacraments. And this applies not only to Catholic Christians, but to all the baptized, including non-Catholics. This is the great teaching affirmed with clarity and conviction by the great texts of Vatican II. Let us be fully aware: non-Catholic Christians have a spiritual need to receive the conferral of grace through the administration of the Sacraments. They therefore have a spiritual need to receive the Sacraments. We can also say that non-Catholic Christians have the right to receive the Sacraments. And the Catholic Church has the duty to administer the Sacraments to these Christians. All this can be understood as a concrete application of the principle of grace to be procured, note the gerund, which indicates necessity” (edited by Andrea Tornielli, here).
Carrying the reasoning through to its conclusion, one may ask whether a married couple, one Catholic and the other not in full communion with the Church, participating together in Holy Mass and desiring also to receive the Eucharist, might constitute an exceptional case — if this corresponds to a spiritual need of the spouses, who would otherwise experience that moment as separated or would not experience it at all, abstaining from it. The expert prelate responds as follows:
“If the Catholic minister were to administer Holy Communion to the non-Catholic spouse, everyone could reasonably consider that such a concession is determined by the just necessity of not separating a married couple, especially at such a special moment as participation in the sacrament of the Eucharist. All this can, in any case, always be clarified through an explanatory catechesis offered to the community of the faithful, even on a recurring basis.”
I do not wish to dwell too long on this topic, also because the focus, as mentioned at the beginning, is another. Much more could be said, since the matter is still being studied and deepened, and I have not mentioned — precisely in order not to prolong the discussion — the prior conditions or the spiritual dispositions that must be present in those who, although not in full communion with the Church, may in specific and exceptional cases receive from a Catholic minister the sacraments of grace. It is also evident that all this belongs to a sphere rigorously regulated by the law of the Church and cannot in any way be confused with forms of indiscriminate intercommunion or, worse, with Eucharistic celebrations that disregard full ecclesial communion and the validity of the priestly ministry. Precisely because this is a delicate matter, reference to exceptional cases must never be taken as an ordinary criterion, but as confirmation that the Church, while firmly safeguarding the meaning of her spiritual goods, does not cease to question how to provide them, where permitted, for the salvation of all souls.
As one can imagine, all this reasoning — which from the Council has found its way into the Code — arises both from theological reflection on the spiritual goods of the Church, which by their nature are meant to be poured out abundantly and can hardly be denied to those who request them with trust, respect and proper disposition, and from the recognition that the human situations people experience in this world are manifold and varied. And the Church, which safeguards the treasures of divine grace, cannot but reflect on this.
Returning therefore to the question that gave rise to this text, the answer can only be affirmative. The Church can grant a blessing, albeit with many distinctions, even to those who live in exceptional, particular or irregular situations. Especially if these persons are baptized in communion with the Church, even if they live in a life situation that the Church considers erroneous. If they can, under the proper conditions, receive the Sacraments like all the other baptized — and, as we have seen, even those belonging to another confession can do so when they are unable to turn to their own ministers — why not also a simple blessing, which would serve only to reaffirm what the Church has always done: reject sin but welcome and love the sinner, as the Lord has taught?
It remains necessary, however, to clarify that such a blessing could never rightly be understood as a confirmation, ratification or legitimation of the objective condition in which such persons find themselves. If that were the case, both the meaning of the blessing and the truth of ecclesial pastoral care would be betrayed. The Church, in fact, can bless the person who asks God for help, not sin as such, nor the claim that a situation contrary to her doctrine should thereby be recognized as morally good or ecclesially legitimate. Precisely for this reason the blessing, if requested with faith and humility, preserves its meaning only if it remains an act of invocation, of entrustment and of accompaniment, never of implicit consecration of a state of life.
As was specified at the time by the Prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith in the above-mentioned press release, the purpose of the Declaration — which, it must be admitted, some have found difficult to accept — was to highlight the value of blessing for the Church, in order to arrive at “a broader understanding of blessings and the proposal to increase pastoral blessings, which do not require the same conditions as blessings in a liturgical or ritual context.”
Since we no longer live in a Christianized context, the Church will increasingly encounter situations that are not regular according to doctrine. She may take refuge in a defensive position and simply entrench herself behind doctrine, which recognizes the unlawfulness of certain human conditions, but this would say nothing new. Or, following the example of her Master, she may acknowledge that a relationship is erroneous and yet contains within itself positive elements that cannot be denied, and therefore why not pour upon these situations “the oil of consolation and the wine of hope,” even a simple informal blessing when requested with trust?
Here too, however, discernment remains decisive: one thing is to offer pastoral assistance to persons who, though in an objectively disordered or irregular condition, ask for spiritual help without claiming any form of legitimation; another would be to endorse, even indirectly, the claim that ecclesial welcome coincides with recognizing their condition as in conformity with the Gospel. The Church’s mercy does not consist in obscuring the truth, but in accompanying persons toward it with patience, without rejecting or humiliating anyone, while at the same time falsifying nothing.
Here, then, is a small contribution to a reflection that makes no claim to completeness, moved only by that spirit which lies behind Jesus’ invitation to be a disciple “like a householder who brings out of his treasure what is new and what is old” (Mt 13:52). Precisely for this reason, the task of the Church is neither to close the door of grace to those who ask for it with sincere trust, nor to confuse mercy with the legitimation of what remains contrary to the Gospel, but to safeguard together truth and charity, so that every pastoral act may be a genuine help to persons and never an occasion for misunderstanding concerning doctrine. All this without ever losing sight of the very essence of the mission entrusted to us by Christ in these precise words:
“Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick. Go and learn what this means: I desire mercy, and not sacrifice. For I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners” (Mt 9:12–13).
From the Hermitage, March 19, 2026
.
THE VARIOUS FACETS OF BLESSING
The Church can give the blessing, although with many distinctions, also to those who live in exceptional situations, private or irregular. Particularly if these people are baptized in communion with the Church, even if they live a life situation that the Church considers erroneous.
The Declaration Begging for Confidence, December 2023, It referred to the possibility of blessing irregular couples and even same-sex couples.. Your reception, at first, must have provoked contrasting responses in the episcopate, If already in January of the following year the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith felt the need to issue a statement with details about the simple nature, informal and pastoral of said blessings, without creating confusion with the doctrine regarding marriage or with ritualized liturgical blessings. In the same context, reference was made to the possibility of a gradual acceptance of the Declaration or even its non-reception in the most delicate and difficult cases.. However, its value was emphasized, as the possibility of remaining attentive to the requests that arise from the faithful and of offering them an adequate catechesis in this regard.
Towards the end of an article published in this same magazine, which dealt with the topic of homosexuality and the Bible (Here), The wish was expressed that the path of reflection on these questions would not be abandoned. With this writing, despite its brevity and the insufficiency of its author, I would like to continue this task, answering the question of whether it is fair to grant a spiritual good to the Church, How can the blessing be?, also to those who live in a situation that we could define as particular, which constitutes an exception - if you want to avoid the recurring term that refers to irregularity - starting from what the Church already does in other situations or extending it.
In the Code of Canon Law of the Catholic Church The issue of intercommunion with separated brothers is discussed; in particular, the canon 844 addresses the question of the administration of the Sacraments by a minister of the Church to the faithful who are not in full communion with the Catholic Church, la llamada communion in the sacred. The text considers two categories of non-Catholic Christians: the "members of the Eastern Churches" (§ 3) and "the other Christians", that is to say, those belonging to Western Christian denominations, those that have existed in the West since the time of the Reformation (§ 4). For both categories the canonical text states that "Catholic ministers licitly administer the sacraments of penance.", of the Eucharist and the anointing of the sick" (§§ 3-4). Of both categories, the same canon reaffirms that "they are not in full communion with the Catholic Church." (§§ 3-4); which means — said positively — that these Christians are in true communion with the Catholic Church, although not complete (cf. especially The light, n. 15; Reintegratio, NN. 3,1; 22,2).
More particularly, the canon 844 § 4 demand that, for the administration of the Sacraments by the Catholic Church to non-Catholic Christians belonging to Western confessions, there must be a serious and urgent need. However, the encyclical To be one, in the number 46, also speaks of the existence of "particular cases", and Church of the Eucharist, in the number 45, also refers to "special circumstances". Since the Code of Canon Law essentially depends on the Second Vatican Council, one cannot fail to mention the most important text on this topic, that is to say, Reintegratio, n. 8, that is how it is expressed: «The intercommunion (in the Sacraments) It depends above all on two principles: "of the manifestation of the unity of the Church and of participation in the means of grace". The manifestation of unity usually prohibits intercommunion. Participation in grace, the grace to be procured, sometimes he recommends it.
Naturally, the first principle serves to safeguard ecclesial communion and avoid the danger of error or indifferentism, as if administering the Sacraments to Catholics and those who are not Catholics were the same, which is not, without risk of misunderstanding. Maintaining that there is no difference between being in communion with the Catholic Church or not would lead to disorientation and scandal.. On the other hand - and I return here to the words of Cardinal Coccopalmerio, president emeritus of the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts —:
«The second principle recalls the need to confer grace on the part of the Catholic Church not in any way, but specifically through the administration of the Sacraments. And this applies not only to Catholic Christians., but for all the baptized, also for non-Catholics. This is the great teaching affirmed with clarity and conviction by the great text of Vatican II. Let us be fully aware: Non-Catholic Christians have a spiritual need to receive grace through the administration of the Sacraments. Have, therefore, the spiritual need to receive the Sacraments. We can also say that non-Catholic Christians have the right to receive the Sacraments. And the Catholic Church has the duty to administer them to these Christians.. All this can be considered as a concrete determination of the principle of grace to be procured, observe the gerund as a sign of necessity» (edited by Andrea Tornielli, here).
Taking reasoning to its ultimate consequences, When asked if a married couple, one Catholic and the other not in full communion with the Church, participating together in the Holy Mass and also wishing to receive the Eucharist, may constitute an exceptional case - if this responds to a spiritual need of the spouses who would otherwise live that moment apart or would not live it at all -, the expert prelate responds like this:
"If the Catholic minister were to administer Holy Communion to the non-Catholic spouse, everyone could reasonably consider that such a concession is determined by the just need not to separate a married couple, especially in such a special moment as participation in the sacrament of the Eucharist. All this can, in any case, always be clarified through an explanatory catechesis offered to the community of the faithful, even recurrently.
I don't want to go into too much detail on this topic., also because the focus, as indicated at the beginning, is another. Many other things could be said, since the issue continues to be the subject of study and deepening, and I have not mentioned - precisely so as not to lengthen - the preconditions or spiritual dispositions that must be present in whoever, even though they are not in full communion with the Church, can, in specific and exceptional cases, receive the sacraments of grace from a Catholic minister. It is also evident that all this belongs to an area rigorously regulated by the law of the Church and cannot in any way be confused with forms of indiscriminate intercommunion or, even worse, with Eucharistic celebrations that disregard full ecclesial communion and the validity of the priestly ministry. Precisely because it is a delicate matter, The reference to exceptional cases should never be assumed as an ordinary criterion, but as confirmation that the Church, still firmly guarding the meaning of their spiritual goods, You keep wondering how to get them, in permitted cases, for the salvation of all souls.
As you can imagine, All this reasoning - which since the Council has passed into the Code - arises both from theological reflection on the spiritual goods of the Church, who by their very nature want to be poured out in abundance and can hardly refuse those who ask for them with confidence, respect and good disposition, as well as the fact that the human situations that people live in this world are multiple and varied.. and the Church, that guards the treasures of divine grace, You can't help but wonder about it..
coming back, therefore, to the topic that gave rise to this writing, The answer cannot but be affirmative.. The Church can give the blessing, although with many distinctions, also to those who live in exceptional situations, private or irregular. Particularly if these people are baptized in communion with the Church, even if they live a life situation that the Church considers erroneous. If they can, in proper conditions, receive the Sacraments like all other baptized people — and, as we have seen, even those belonging to another denomination can do so when they cannot turn to their own ministers —, why not also a simple blessing, that would only serve to reaffirm what the Church has always done: reject sin, but welcome and love the sinner, as the Lord has taught?
However, It is necessary to specify that a blessing of this type could never be correctly understood as confirmation, ratification or legitimation of the objective condition in which such people find themselves. If so, both the meaning of the blessing and the very truth of ecclesial pastoral care would be betrayed.. The Church can bless the person who asks God for help, not sin as such, nor the claim that a situation contrary to its doctrine be recognized as morally good or ecclesially legitimate. Precisely for this reason, the blessing, if asked with faith and humility, retains its meaning only if it remains as a gesture of invocation, of trust and support, never as an implicit consecration of a condition of life.
As the prefect of the Dicastery specified at the time for the Doctrine of the Faith in the aforementioned statement, the objective of the Declaration — that, you have to admit it, some have digested poorly — was to highlight the value of the blessing for the Church, in order to arrive at a "broader understanding of the blessings and the proposal to increase pastoral blessings, "that do not require the same conditions as blessings in a liturgical or ritual context".
By not living for a long time in a Christianized context, The Church will increasingly encounter situations that do not conform to doctrine. He may entrench himself in a defensive position and limit himself to taking refuge behind the doctrine that recognizes the illegality of certain human conditions., but this wouldn't say anything new. Or, following the example of his Master, You will be able to recognize that a relationship is wrong and, however, It contains positive elements within it that cannot be denied., And then why not pour out “the oil of consolation and the wine of hope” on these situations?, even with a simple informal blessing, if requested with confidence?
Also here, however, discernment remains decisive: It is one thing to pastorally accompany people who, even in an objectively disordered or irregular condition, They ask for spiritual help without seeking any legitimacy; another thing would be to endorse, even indirectly, the claim that ecclesial welcome coincides with the recognition of its state as conforming to the Gospel. The mercy of the Church does not consist in obscuring the truth, but in accompanying people towards it with patience, without rejecting or humiliating anyone, but at the same time without falsifying anything.
Behold, well, a small contribution to reflection that has no pretensions, moved only by that spirit that is behind Jesus' invitation to be a disciple "similar to a householder who brings out of his treasure new things and old things" (Mt 13,52). Precisely for that reason, The task of the Church is not to close the door of grace to those who ask for it with sincere trust., nor confuse mercy with the legitimation of what remains contrary to the Gospel, but to jointly guard truth and charity, so that each pastoral gesture is an authentic help for people and never an occasion for misunderstanding about doctrine. All this, without ever losing sight of the very essence of the mission that Christ has entrusted to us with precise words:
«The healthy have no need of a doctor, but the sick. Id, well, and learn what it means: I want mercy and not sacrifice. Because I have not come to call the righteous, but to sinners" (Mt 9,12-13).
From the Eremo, 19 March 2026
.
.
Sant'Angelo Cave in Ripe (Civitella del Tronto)
.
Visit the pages of our book shop WHO and support our editions by purchasing and distributing our books.
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of: Editions The island of Patmos n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff, the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
.
.
.
.
.
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/monaco-eremita-piccolo-.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150Hermit MonkHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngHermit Monk2026-03-19 13:03:532026-03-20 11:54:02The various facets of blessing – The various facets of blessing – The various facets of blessing
CONDOLENCE FOR THE DEATH OF ABABOT UGO GIANLUIGI TAGNI
The Most Rev. Dom Ugo Gianluigi Tagni has returned to the house of the Father, of the Cistercian Order, Abbot emeritus of Casamari Abbey
– The briefs of the Fathers of the Isle of Patmos –
Author Editors of The Island of Patmos
.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos join in fraternal condolences to the family of Cistercian Monks for the death of the Most Rev. Dom Ugo Gianluigi Tagni, Abbot emeritus of Casamari Abbey, man of human and spiritual qualities as great as they are rare.
The funeral obsequies they will take place tomorrow, 17 February, at 15:00, in the abbey church of Casamari.
(In the picture: Abbot Ugo Gianluigi Tagni and Father Ariel S. Levi di Gualdo)
We entrust his soul to the Intercession of Mater Dei with the Prayer of Saint Bernard to the Blessed Virgin Mary.
Rome, 16 February 2026
.
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Those who wish to support our apostolic work can send us their contribution through the convenient and safe way PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of: Editions The island of Patmos n Agency. 59 Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff, the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos
.
.
HTTPS://i0.wp.com/isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/faviconbianco150.jpg?fit=150,150&ssl=1150150father arielHTTPS://isoladipatmos.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/logo724c.pngfather ariel2026-02-16 22:41:242026-02-17 09:19:54Condolences for the death of Abbot Ugo Gianluigi Tagni
We use cookies to improve your experience. You can accept them all or manage your preferences.
Functional
Always active
Technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
Technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences which are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
Technical storage or access that is used solely for statistical purposes.Technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance by your Internet Service Provider, or further registrations by third parties, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used for identification.
Marketing
Technical storage or access is required to create profiles of users to send advertising, or to track you across a website or websites for similar marketing purposes.