The difficult but possible march of the saints in the song of the slaves of New Orleans ― The difficult but possible march of the saints in the song of the slaves of New Orleans
THE DIFFICULT BUT POSSIBLE MARCH OF THE SAINTS IN THE SONG OF THE SLAVES OF NEW ORLEANS
Holiness is not the prize reserved for those who have never made mistakes, but the point of arrival of those who have never stopped letting themselves be reached by God.
— Catechesis —
.

Author
Ariel S. Levi di Gualdo
.
![]()
PDF print format article – article print format – article in printed format
.
A New Orleans, in the first decades of the twentieth century, funerals had their own ritual. The band accompanied the coffin towards the cemetery at a slow pace, playing funeral marches. On the way back, buried the deceased, the same band was playing an old African-American Spiritual at full speed: When the Saints Go Marching In.
Who was witnessing it for the first time he could mistake it for irreverence. Instead, it was a profession of faith played on trumpet and trombone: death does not have the last word. Made famous worldwide by Louis Armstrong in 1938, the song has become so familiar that it is sung in stadiums and parties, completely forgetting its origin. Its refrain says:
«Oh, when the saints go marching in, / Oh Lord, I want to be in that number, / when the saints go marching in» («Oh, when the saints enter in procession, / man, I want to be in that number, / when the saints enter in procession").
Two words deserve attention. The first is «in». The saints do not parade through the streets like any other parade: they enter, they cross the threshold of the heavenly Jerusalem. The second is «that number», that number. The slaves and the children of slaves who sang this spiritual knew the Bible better than many theologians: that number is that of the Apocalypse, where after i 144.000 «an immense multitude appears, that no one could count, of every nation, tribe, people and language" (AP 7,9). It is the first reading of the All Saints' Mass. In a song born among blacks enslaved and then discriminated against by racial segregation, who were denied even the dignity of persons, hope had the precise characteristics of the liturgy of the Church: enter that number.
A call to everyone
"Be holy, why me, the Sir, your God, I am holy" (Lv 19,2). "Oh, so, be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect" (Mt 5,48). «This is in fact the will of God, your sanctification" (1Ts 4,3). Scripture does not know a sanctity for a few specialists of the spirit, nor a career reserved for those who wear religious habit. The Second Vatican Council reiterated this without ambiguity: «all the faithful of any state or degree are called to the fullness of Christian life and to the perfection of charity»¹. It is a sanctity that does not only live in cloisters and on altars, but in homes, in the workplace, in hospital wards, everywhere a man or a woman lives faithfully, day by day, what God has entrusted to them.
If holiness was something unattainable, God would have commanded us the impossible. And God does not make fun of his creatures.
What holiness really is
In the common imagination, holiness coincides with impeccability, with wonders, with ecstasies, with fasts prolonged beyond all reason. All things that can accompany the life of a saint, but which do not constitute its essence. Saint Thomas Aquinas says it with his usual sobriety: the perfection of the Christian life essentially consists in charity². The saint is not first and foremost the one who has not sinned, but he who loved God and his neighbor to the end, letting grace work in him until it transformed him.
This does not mean that sainthood is a moral achievement, the fruit of a gymnastics of the will. It is first and foremost a gift that God offers and that man is called to welcome. But hospitality is not passivity: «The path to perfection passes through the cross. There is no holiness without renunciation and without spiritual combat"³. Holiness is not the prize reserved for those who have never made mistakes, but the point of arrival of those who have never stopped letting themselves be reached by God.
Just scroll through the lives of quite a few saints to realize it: Augustine of Hippo lived for years with a concubine, with whom he had a son, Adeodato, before surrendering to grace. Mary of Egypt, according to the Vita written by Sophronius of Jerusalem, she prostituted herself for seventeen years in Alexandria, Egypt⁴. Margherita da Cortona was the lover of a young nobleman from Montepulciano for about ten years, to whom he bore a son. Moses the Ethiopian, before becoming one of the great Desert Fathers, he had been the leader of a band of bandits. Camillo de Lellis, soldier of fortune, he was a slave to gambling to the point of losing everything he owned, up to the shirt. Ignatius of Loyola, by his own admission, up to the age of twenty-six he was a man devoted to the vanities of the world⁵. Charles de Foucauld, young cavalry officer, he was noted more for his revelry and mistresses than for his discipline. Bartolo Longo, before founding the sanctuary of Pompeii, he frequented the spiritualist circles of Naples until he declared himself a consecrated priest of Satan; Leo XIV proclaimed him a saint in 2025. None of them were born saints. Everyone became one, not passing by sin, but through it, until grace reached them and found them, Finally, willing to let themselves be reached.
From martyrs to confessors
In the first centuries the saints venerated by the Church were martyrs. The Eucharist was celebrated on their tombs on the anniversary of their death, named birthday, day of birth to heaven. The blood shed for Christ was the unmistakable sign of holiness. But when with the peace of Constantine the persecutions stopped, a new question was asked: you can be holy without shedding blood? The answer has a name: Martin of Tours, soldier, monaco, bishop, d. 397. He was among the first, if not the first, in the West to receive public worship despite not being a martyr. His biographer Sulpicius Severus explained it like this:
«Although the conditions of the times could not offer him martyrdom, he will not be deprived of the glory of the martyr, because with desire and virtue he could and wanted to be a martyr"⁶.
Thus was born the figure of the "confessor", he who bears witness to Christ not with violent death, but with the daily gift of life. It must be said, for historical accuracy, that in Martin's time canonization did not exist: the cult arose from below, by the reputation of holiness among the people and the approval of the local bishop. The first formal canonization pronounced by a Roman Pontiff was that of Ulrich of Augsburg, proclaimed saint by John XV in 993.
Saints are not born
Over the centuries we have idealized the saints to the point of making them inimitable. That nice and imaginative Dominican who was Jacopo da Varazze, archbishop of Genoa, in its Golden legend tells without any fear of falling into ridicule that Saint Nicholas, still an infant, on Wednesdays and Fridays she took breast milk only once a day, to observe the fast⁷. A newborn already observing the penitential calendar, in conclusion. Baroque hagiography has multiplied saints who showed heroic virtues from their cradle and devotional holy cards did the rest, giving us angelic figures, with eyes turned to the sky, without a shadow of internal struggle. The result was paradoxical: precisely because they were perfect from the start, the saints have become models to be admired from a distance, not to be imitated. And so we felt excused from trying, thanks precisely to the various Jacopo da Varazze.
The reality is very different. Paul of Tarsus persecuted the Church by entering homes and dragging men and women to prison (cf.. At 8,3) and until the end he defined himself as the first of sinners (cf.. 1TM 1,15). Francis of Assisi, before embracing Madonna Poverty, he was the king of the revelry of the youth of Assisi⁸. Saints were not born saints: they became, often after long years of living even in the most serious sins.
What many don't know, or maybe they don't remember, is that the first saint proclaimed as such was a criminal sentenced to death. Crucified next to Jesus, unlike the other criminal who insulted him, he turned to him saying: "Jesus, remember me when you enter your kingdom ". And Jesus answered him: "Verily I say unto thee: today you will be with me in paradise" (LC 23,42-43). If ever there was a canonization, Christ himself celebrated it, from the cross, without trial, without a postulator and without confirmed miracles. The most surprising detail is another: according to Matthew and Mark, even that thief, At first, he insulted Jesus together with his companion (cf.. Mt 27,44; MC 15,32). The saint who tradition will call Dismas⁹ came out of who, until shortly before, determined. It is all the theology of grace contained in a few moments: no one is too far to reach, not even at the last breath.
The nameless army
All Saints' Day has a long history. In 609 Pope Boniface IV dedicated the Pantheon in Rome to the Virgin Mary and all the martyrs. In the following century Gregory III consecrated an oratory to all the saints in St. Peter's Basilica and set the celebration for November 1st, a date that Gregory IV then extended to the entire Church in 835.
But the profound meaning of this solemnity escapes many. It is not first and foremost the feast of saints canonized and included in the calendar, each of which already has its own day. It is the celebration of that "immense multitude, that no one could count" (AP 7,9): the endless army of unknown saints that no Dicastery for the Causes of Saints has ever examined, nor will he ever examine. The grandmother who recited the rosary every evening for a grandson far from the faith. The family man who worked honestly for forty years without ever stealing a euro. The parish priest of a mountain town forgotten by everyone, except from God. The patient who offered his suffering without making it a banner. None of them will have a statue, an image, a party. Yet they are them, to a large extent, "that number".
The French writer Léon Bloy he closed one of his novels with a phrase that has remained famous: «There is nothing but sadness, that of not being saints"¹⁰. All Saints reminds us that this sadness is not a condemnation, because the door remains open until the last moment, as that thief on the cross experienced. The march of the saints is difficult, no one denies it. But it's possible, because there is no unattainable model walking in front of us, but an innumerable crowd of men and women who, sinners like us, they allowed themselves to be saved.
When the New Orleans gang returned from the cemetery, people took to the streets and joined the procession in dancing. He didn't just listen: entered the queue. This is the invitation of All Saints. And the most sincere prayer we can address to God on this day is perhaps precisely that of the spiritual of the slaves of America: «Oh Lord, I want to be in that number»: man, I want to be in that number.
From the island of Patmos, 1November 2026
.
NOTE
¹ Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church The light, n. 40.
² Cfr. Thomas Aquinas, QUESTION, II-II, q. 184, a. 1.
³ Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 2015.
⁴ Cfr. Sophronius of Jerusalem, Life of Saint Mary of Egypt.
⁵ Cfr. Ignatius of Loyola, Autobiography, n. 1.
⁶ Sulpicius Severus, Letter (II), 9. Our translation.
⁷ Cfr. Jacopo da Varazze, Golden legend, cap. "Saint Nicholas".
⁸ Cfr. Thomas of Celano, Life before Saint Francis, I, 1-2.
⁹ The name appears in the Gospel of Nicodemus (O Acts of Pilate), 10, apocryphal writing.
¹⁰ L. Bloy, The poor woman (1897), the last page.
.
THE DIFFICULT YET POSSIBLE MARCH OF THE SAINTS IN THE SONG OF THE SLAVES OF NEW ORLEANS
Holiness is not a prize reserved for those who have never gone wrong, but the destination of those who have never stopped letting God reach them.
— Catechesis —

Author
Ariel S. Levi di Gualdo
.
In New Orleans, in the early decades of the twentieth century, funerals had a ritual all their own. The band accompanied the coffin to the cemetery at a slow pace, playing funeral marches. On the way back, once the deceased had been buried, the same band would strike up, at full tempo, an old Negro spiritual: When the Saints Go Marching In. Anyone witnessing it for the first time might have mistaken it for irreverence. It was instead a profession of faith played on trumpet and trombone: death does not have the last word. Made famous throughout the world by Louis Armstrong in 1938, the song has become so familiar that it is sung in stadiums and at parties, its origin entirely forgotten. Its refrain goes:
«Oh, when the saints go marching in, / Oh Lord, I want to be in that number, / when the saints go marching in».
Two words deserve attention. The first is «in». The saints do not file through the streets like any ordinary parade: they go in, they cross the threshold of the heavenly Jerusalem. The second is «that number». The slaves and the children of slaves who sang this spiritual knew the Bible better than not a few theologians: that number is the one in the Book of Revelation where, after the hundred and forty-four thousand who were sealed, there appears «a great multitude, which no one could count, from every nation, race, people, and tongue» (Rev 7:9). It is the first reading of the Mass of All Saints. In a song born among Negroes held in slavery and later discriminated against under racial segregation, who were denied even the dignity of persons, hope bore the precise features of the Church’s liturgy: to enter that number.
A call addressed to all
«Be holy, for I, the LORD your God, am holy» (Lev 19:2). «So be perfect, just as your heavenly Father is perfect» (Mt 5:48). «This is the will of God, your holiness» (1 Thes 4:3). Scripture knows no holiness for a few specialists of the spirit, nor a career reserved for those who wear a religious habit. The Second Vatican Council restated this without ambiguity: «all the faithful of Christ of whatever rank or status, are called to the fullness of the Christian life and to the perfection of charity»¹. It is a holiness that dwells not only in cloisters and on altars, but in homes, in workplaces, in hospital wards, wherever a man or a woman lives out faithfully, day after day, what God has entrusted to them.
If holiness were something unattainable, God would have commanded us to do the impossible. And God does not make fools of his creatures.
What holiness really is
In the popular imagination, holiness is identified with sinlessness, with miracles, with ecstasies, with fasts prolonged beyond all reason. All things that may accompany the life of a saint, but that do not constitute its essence. Saint Thomas Aquinas puts it with his usual sobriety: the perfection of the Christian life consists essentially in charity². The saint is not first of all the one who has never sinned, but the one who has loved God and neighbour to the very end, letting grace work in him until it transformed him.
This does not mean that holiness is a moral achievement, the fruit of some gymnastics of the will. It is first of all a gift that God offers and that man is called to receive. But receiving is not passivity: «The way of perfection passes by way of the Cross. There is no holiness without renunciation and spiritual battle»³. Holiness is not a prize reserved for those who have never gone wrong, but the destination of those who have never stopped letting God reach them.
One need only glance through the lives of not a few saints to see this. Augustine of Hippo lived for years with a concubine, by whom he had a son, Adeodatus, before surrendering to grace. Mary of Egypt, according to the Life written by Sophronius of Jerusalem, lived as a prostitute in Alexandria for seventeen years⁴. Margaret of Cortona was for some ten years the mistress of a young nobleman of Montepulciano, to whom she bore a son. Moses the Ethiopian, before becoming one of the great Desert Fathers, had been the leader of a band of brigands. Camillus de Lellis, a soldier of fortune, was so enslaved to gambling that he lost everything he owned, down to the shirt on his back. Ignatius of Loyola, by his own admission, was until the age of twenty-six a man given to the vanities of the world⁵. Charles de Foucauld, as a young cavalry officer, was known more for his carousing and his mistresses than for his discipline. Bartolo Longo, before founding the shrine of Pompeii, frequented the spiritualist circles of Naples to the point of declaring himself consecrated a priest of Satan; Leo XIV proclaimed him a saint in 2025. None of them was born a saint. All of them became saints, passing not alongside sin but through it, until grace reached them and found them, at last, willing to let themselves be reached.
From martyrs to confessors
In the first centuries the saints venerated by the Church were the martyrs. The Eucharist was celebrated over their tombs on the anniversary of their death, called the birthday, the day of their birth into heaven. Blood shed for Christ was the unmistakable sign of holiness. But when the persecutions ceased with the Peace of Constantine, a new question arose: can one be a saint without shedding one’s blood? The answer has a name: Martin of Tours, soldier, monk and bishop, who died in 397. He was among the first, if not the very first, in the West to receive public veneration without having been a martyr. His biographer Sulpicius Severus explained it thus:
«Although the circumstances of his time could not offer him martyrdom, he will not lack the glory of a martyr, because by desire and by virtue he both could have been and wished to be a martyr»⁶.
Thus was born the figure of the «confessor», one who bears witness to Christ not by a violent death but by the daily gift of his life. For the sake of historical accuracy, it should be said that canonisation did not exist in Martin’s day: veneration arose from below, from a reputation for holiness among the people and from the approval of the local bishop. The first formal canonisation pronounced by a Roman Pontiff was that of Ulrich of Augsburg, declared a saint by John XV in 993.
Saints are not born
Over the centuries we have idealised the saints to the point of making them inimitable. That likeable and imaginative Dominican, Jacopo da Varazze, archbishop of Genoa, relates in his Golden Legend, without the slightest fear of looking ridiculous, that Saint Nicholas, while still a nursing infant, took his mother’s milk only once a day on Wednesdays and Fridays, so as to keep the fast⁷. A newborn already keeping the penitential calendar, in short. Baroque hagiography multiplied saints who displayed heroic virtue from the cradle, and devotional holy cards did the rest, handing down to us angelic figures with eyes turned heavenwards and not a shadow of inner struggle. The result was paradoxical: precisely because they were perfect from the start, the saints became models to be admired from afar, not imitated. And so we felt excused from even trying, thanks precisely to the likes of Jacopo da Varazze.
The reality is quite different. Paul of Tarsus persecuted the Church, entering house after house and dragging men and women off to prison (cf. Acts 8:3), and to the very end called himself the foremost of sinners (cf. 1 Tim 1:15). Francis of Assisi, before embracing Lady Poverty, was the king of the revels among the young men of Assisi⁸. The saints were not born such: they became saints, often after long years spent even in the gravest sins.
What many do not know, or perhaps do not remember, is that the first saint ever proclaimed as such was a criminal condemned to death. Crucified beside Jesus, unlike the other wrongdoer who reviled him, he turned to him and said: «Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom». And Jesus replied: «Amen, I say to you, today you will be with me in Paradise» (Page 23:42-43). If there was ever a canonisation, Christ himself celebrated it, from the cross, with no trial, no postulator and no verified miracles. The most surprising detail lies elsewhere: according to Matthew and Mark, that thief too at first reviled Jesus together with his companion (cf. Mt 27:44; Mk 15:32). The saint whom tradition would call Dismas⁹ came forth from a man who, moments earlier, had been blaspheming. The whole theology of grace is contained in those few moments: no one is too far away to be reached, not even at his last breath.
The nameless army
The feast of All Saints has a long history. In 609 Pope Boniface IV dedicated the Pantheon in Rome to the Virgin Mary and all the martyrs. In the following century Gregory III consecrated an oratory to all the saints in Saint Peter’s Basilica and fixed the celebration on 1 November, a date that Gregory IV extended to the whole Church in 835.
Yet the deeper meaning of this solemnity escapes many. It is not first of all the feast of the canonised saints listed in the calendar, each of whom already has a day of his or her own. It is the feast of that «great multitude, which no one could count» (Rev 7:9): the countless army of unknown saints whom no Dicastery for the Causes of Saints has ever examined, nor ever will. The grandmother who prayed the rosary every evening for a grandchild who had drifted from the faith. The father who worked honestly for forty years without ever stealing a single cent. The parish priest of a mountain village forgotten by everyone except God. The sick man who offered up his suffering without turning it into a banner. None of them will have a statue, an image, a feast day. Yet it is they, for the most part, who make up «that number».
The French writer Léon Bloy ended one of his novels with a sentence that has become famous: «There is only one sadness: not to be saints»¹⁰. All Saints reminds us that this sadness is not a condemnation, because the door remains open until the very last moment, as that thief on the cross discovered. The march of the saints is difficult; no one denies it. But it is possible, because what walks ahead of us is not an unattainable model, but an innumerable crowd of men and women who, sinners like us, allowed themselves to be saved.
When the New Orleans band came back from the cemetery, people poured into the streets and joined the procession, dancing. They did not merely listen: they fell into line. This is the invitation of All Saints. And the most sincere prayer we can address to God on this day is perhaps precisely that of the old slaves spiritual: «Oh Lord, I want to be in that number».
From The Island of Patmos, 1 November 2026
NOTES
¹ Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church The light, n. 40.
² Cf. Thomas Aquinas, QUESTION, II-II, q. 184, a. 1.
³ Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 2015.
⁴ Cf. Sophronius of Jerusalem, Life of Saint Mary of Egypt.
⁵ Cf. Ignatius of Loyola, Autobiography, n. 1.
⁶ Sulpicius Severus, Letter (II), 9. Our translation.
⁷ Cf. Jacopo da Varazze, Golden Legend, chapter «Saint Nicholas».
⁸ Cf. Thomas of Celano, First Life of Saint Francis, I, 1-2.
⁹ The name appears in the Gospel of Nicodemus (or Acts of Pilate), 10, an apocryphal text.
¹⁰ L. Bloy, The poor woman (1897), last page. Our translation.
.
THE DIFFICULT BUT POSSIBLE MARCH OF THE SAINTS IN THE SONG OF THE SLAVES OF NEW ORLEANS
Holiness is not the prize reserved for those who have never made a mistake, but the goal of those who have never stopped letting themselves be reached by God.

Author
Ariel S. Levi di Gualdo
.
In New Orleans, in the first decades of the 20th century, funerals had a very particular ritual. The band accompanied the coffin towards the cemetery at a slow pace, playing funeral marches. On the way back, once the deceased has been buried, the same band started at full speed with an old spiritual from the blacks of America: When the Saints Go Marching In. Anyone who witnessed it for the first time could take it for irreverence.. Era, instead, a profession of faith played with trumpet and trombone: death does not have the last word. Popularized around the world by Louis Armstrong in 1938, The song has become so familiar that it is sung in stadiums and at parties, completely forgetting its origin. Its chorus says:
«Oh, when the saints go marching in, / Oh Lord, I want to be in that number, / when the saints go marching in» («Oh, when the saints enter into procession, / Señor, I want to be in that number, / "when the saints enter into procession").
Two words deserve attention. The first is «in». The saints do not walk the streets like in any parade: they enter, cross the threshold of the heavenly Jerusalem. The second is "that number», that number. The slaves and children of slaves who sang this spiritual knew the Bible better than many theologians.: that number is that of the Apocalypse, where, after the one hundred and forty-four thousand marked with the seal, "an immense crowd appears, that no one could tell, of all nations, breeds, peoples and languages (AP 7,9). It is the first reading of the Mass of All Saints. In a song born among blacks reduced to slavery and later discriminated against by racial segregation, who were denied even the dignity of persons, hope had the precise features of the liturgy of the Church: enter that number.
A call to everyone
«Sed santos, because I, the Lord, your God, "I am holy" (Lv 19,2). "Therefore, but perfected, as your heavenly Father is perfect" (Mt 5,48). «This is the will of God: your sanctification" (1 Tes 4,3). Scripture does not know a holiness for a few specialists of the spirit, nor a career reserved for those who wear a religious habit. The Second Vatican Council reaffirmed it without ambiguity: "all the faithful, of any state or condition, "They are called to the fullness of the Christian life and the perfection of charity"¹. It is a holiness that does not live only in the cloisters and altars., but in the houses, in the workplace, in hospital wards, wherever a man or woman lives faithfully, day after day, what God has entrusted to them.
If holiness were something unattainable, God would have sent us the impossible. And God does not mock his creatures.
What holiness really is
In the common imagination, holiness coincides with sinlessness, with the prodigies, with ecstasies, with fasts prolonged beyond all reasonableness. All things that can accompany the life of a saint, but that do not constitute its essence. Saint Thomas Aquinas says it with his usual sobriety: The perfection of the Christian life consists essentially in charity². The saint is not above all one who has not sinned, but who has loved God and neighbor to the end, letting grace work in him until he was transformed.
This does not mean that holiness is a moral achievement, fruit of an gymnastics of the will. It is above all a gift that God offers and that man is called to accept.. But to welcome is not to remain passive.: «The path to perfection passes through the cross. There is no holiness without renunciation and without spiritual combat»³. Holiness is not the prize reserved for those who have never made a mistake, but the goal of those who have never stopped letting themselves be reached by God.
It is enough to go through the lives of many saints to see it.. Augustine of Hippo lived for years with a concubine, from whom he had a son, Adeodato, before surrendering to grace. Egyptian Mary, according to the Life written by Sophronius of Jerusalem, She was a prostitute for seventeen years in Alexandria⁴. Margaret of Cortona was the mistress of a young nobleman from Montepulciano for about ten years., to whom he gave a son. Moses the Ethiopian, before becoming one of the great Desert Fathers, He had been the leader of a gang of robbers. Camilo de Lelis, soldier of fortune, He was a slave to gambling to the point of losing everything he owned., even the shirt. Ignatius of Loyola, according to his own confession, Until he was twenty-six years old he was a man given to the vanities of the world⁵. Charles de Foucauld, young cavalry officer, He was noted more for his carousing and his lovers than for his discipline.. Bartolo Longo, before founding the sanctuary of Pompeii, He frequented the spiritualist circles of Naples until he declared himself a consecrated priest of Satan.; Leo XIV proclaimed him a saint in 2025. None of them were born holy. They all became, not passing by sin, but through him, until grace reached out and found them, at last, willing to let themselves be reached.
From martyrs to confessors
In the first centuries, The saints venerated by the Church were the martyrs. The Eucharist was celebrated on their graves on the anniversary of their death., called birthday, day of birth to heaven. The blood shed by Christ was the unequivocal sign of holiness. but when, with the peace of Constantine, the persecutions stopped, a new question was asked: Can you be holy without shedding blood?? The answer has a name: Martin of Tours, soldier, monk and bishop, died in the year 397. He was one of the first, if not the first, in receiving a public cult in the West without having been a martyr. His biographer Sulpicio Severo explained it this way:
"Although the circumstances of his time could not offer him martyrdom, will not lack the glory of the martyr, because with desire and virtue he could and wanted to be a martyr"⁶.
Thus the figure of the "confessor" was born, he who bears witness to Christ not with a violent death, but with the daily dedication of life. In honor of historical accuracy, It must be said that in Martin's time canonization did not exist: the cult was born from below, of the reputation of holiness among the people and the approval of the local bishop. The first formal canonization pronounced by a Roman Pontiff is that of Ulrich of Augsburg, proclaimed saint by John XV in the year 993.
You are not born holy
Throughout the centuries we have idealized saints until we made them inimitable. That friendly and fanciful Dominican who was Santiago de la Vorágine, Archbishop of Genoa, account in your golden legend, without the slightest fear of falling into ridicule, that Saint Nicholas, still breastfeeding, On Wednesdays and Fridays I drank breast milk only once a day to keep the fast⁷. A newborn already compliant with the penitential calendar, In short. Baroque hagiography multiplied the saints who showed heroic virtues from the cradle and the devotional images did the rest., giving us angelic figures, with eyes turned to heaven, without shadow of internal struggle. The result was paradoxical: precisely because they were perfect from the beginning, the saints became models to admire from a distance, not to imitate. And so we feel excused from trying, thanks precisely to the Santiago de la Vorágine on duty.
The reality is very different. Paul of Tarsus persecuted the Church by entering homes and dragging men and women to prison. (cf. Hch 8,3) and to the end he called himself the chief of sinners (cf. 1 Tim 1,15). Francis of Assisi, before hugging Mrs. Poverty, He was the king of the revelry of the youth of Assisi⁸. Saints were not born such: they became so, often after long years lived in even the most serious sins.
What many do not know, or maybe they don't remember, is that the first saint proclaimed as such was a criminal sentenced to death. Crucified next to Jesus, unlike the other evildoer, that insulted him, He addressed him saying: "Jesus, "Remember me when you come to your kingdom.". And Jesus answered him: "Truly I tell you: Today you will be with me in paradise" (LC 23,42-43). If there ever was a canonization, Christ himself celebrated it, from the cross, without process, without postulator and without proven miracles. The most surprising detail is another: according to Matthew and Mark, also that thief, at first, He insulted Jesus along with his companion (cf. Mt 27,44; MC 15,32). The saint whom tradition will call Dimas⁹ came from whom, shortly before, blasphemous. The entire theology of grace is contained in a few moments: no one is too far to be reached, not even in his last breath.
The nameless army
The festival of All Saints has a long history. In the year 609 Pope Boniface IV dedicated the Pantheon of Rome to the Virgin Mary and all the martyrs. In the following century, Gregory III consecrated an oratory to all the saints in St. Peter's Basilica and fixed the celebration on 1 November, date that Gregory IV later extended to the entire Church in the year 835.
But many miss the deep meaning of this solemnity.. It is not above all the feast of saints canonized and inscribed in the calendar, each of whom already has their own day. It is the celebration of that "immense crowd", that no one could tell (AP 7,9): the innumerable army of unknown saints that no Dicastery of the Causes of Saints has ever examined, nor will it ever examine. The grandmother who prayed the rosary every night for a grandson far from the faith. The father of a family who worked honestly for forty years without ever stealing a euro. The priest of a mountain town forgotten by all, except for God. The sick man who offered his suffering without making it a flag. None of them will have a statue, an image, a party. Y, however, are they, in its vast majority, "that number".
The French writer Léon Bloy He closed one of his novels with a phrase that has become famous: «There is nothing but sadness: that of not being saints»¹⁰. All Saints reminds us that this sadness is not a condemnation, because the door remains open until the last moment, How that thief experienced on the cross. The march of the saints is difficult, no one denies it. But it is possible, because an unattainable model does not walk before us, but an innumerable multitude of men and women who, sinners like us, they allowed themselves to be saved.
When the New Orleans gang returned from the cemetery, people came down to the street and joined the procession dancing. He didn't just listen: entered the line. This is the invitation of All Saints. And the most sincere prayer that we can direct to God on this day is perhaps precisely that of the spiritual of the slaves of America: «Oh Lord, I want to be in that number»: Señor, I want to be in that number.
From the Island of Patmos, 1 November 2026
.
NOTES
¹ Vatican Ecumenical Council II, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church The light, n. 40.
² Cf. Thomas Aquinas, QUESTION, II-II, q. 184, a. 1.
³ Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 2015.
⁴ Cf. Sophronius of Jerusalem, Life of Saint Mary of Egypt.
⁵ Cf. Ignatius of Loyola, Autobiography, n. 1.
⁶ Sulpicius Severus, Epistle (II), 9. Our translation.
⁷ Cf. Santiago de la Voragine, golden legend, cap. "Saint Nicholas".
⁸ Cf. Thomas of Celano, Early life of Saint Francis, I, 1-2.
⁹ The name appears in the Gospel of Nicodemus (O Acts of Pilate), 10, apocryphal writing.
¹⁰ L. Bloy, The poor woman (1897), last page. Our translation.
.
Father Ariel's latest books

book store WHO
.
______________________
Dear Readers, this magazine requires management costs that we have always faced only with your free offers. Anyone who wishes to support our apostolic work, by making a donation even for a small amount, you can send us your contribution conveniently and securely PayPal by clicking below:
Or if you prefer you can use our Bank account in the name of:
Editions The island of Patmos
n Agency. 59 From Rome – Vatican
Iban code: IT74R0503403259000000301118
For international bank transfers:
Codice SWIFT: BAPPIT21D21
If you make a bank transfer, send an email to the editorial staff,
the bank does not provide your email and we will not be able to send you a thank you message: isoladipatmos@gmail.com
We thank you for the support you wish to offer to our apostolic service.
The Fathers of the Island of Patmos












